Out of Peanuts, one case
Packing peanuts substitute: eco-friendly alternatives
5 options, ranked, with the exact amount
Use Biodegradable cornstarch peanuts
Same amount as the peanuts
The best substitutes for packing peanuts are biodegradable cornstarch peanuts, air pillows, crumpled paper, bubble wrap, or shredded paper. Choose based on your shipping needs and environmental preferences.
- Best for —
- fragile items
One casethe full peanuts card
Every option, one card
Ranked| # | Substitute | Instead of peanuts |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Biodegradable cornstarch peanutsfragile items | Same amount |
| 2 | Air pillowsfragile electronics | Same amount |
| 3 | Crumpled paperlightweight items | 2 parts for every 1 partMore paper needed |
| 4 | Bubble wrapfragile items | Same amount |
| 5 | Shredded paperlightweight items | 2 parts for every 1 partMore paper needed |
Biodegradable cornstarch peanuts
N/A · similar texture
Eco-friendly packing peanuts made from cornstarch that dissolve in water
- Best for
- fragile items, heavy objects, irregular shapes, long-term storage, environmentally conscious shipping
Dissolve in water, completely biodegradable, similar protective properties.
Air pillows
N/A · different texture
Inflatable plastic cushions that provide excellent protection
- Best for
- fragile electronics, breakable items, lightweight protection, custom shapes, reusable packaging
Deflate for storage, reusable, excellent shock absorption.
Crumpled paper
N/A · different texture
Newspaper, tissue paper, or packing paper crumpled for protection
- Best for
- lightweight items, budget-friendly shipping, DIY solutions, small packages, temporary protection
Use more material for same protection, completely recyclable.
Bubble wrap
N/A · different texture
Plastic film with air bubbles for cushioning
- Best for
- fragile items, electronics, glass items, artwork, heavy protection needs
Excellent shock absorption, can be reused, not biodegradable.
Shredded paper
N/A · different texture
Cross-cut or strip-cut paper for loose fill protection
- Best for
- lightweight items, eco-friendly shipping, small packages, gift wrapping, temporary storage
Use more volume for same protection, completely recyclable.
How it behaves in this recipe
Packing peanuts are used for protecting items during shipping. When choosing alternatives, consider the fragility of your items, environmental impact, cost, and shipping requirements. Biodegradable options are increasingly popular for eco-conscious shipping.
Tips for substituting peanuts
6 tips- For fragile items, combine multiple materials for better protection
- Test your packaging by shaking the box - items shouldn't move
- Use biodegradable options for environmentally conscious shipping
- Consider the weight of your packaging materials for shipping costs
- Reuse materials when possible to reduce waste
- Choose materials based on the fragility and weight of your items
Notes on peanuts
- Use old clothing or towels for soft item protection
- Try foam sheets or foam peanuts for heavy items
- Consider using popcorn (unpopped) for lightweight protection
- Use crumpled aluminum foil for small, lightweight items
Questions
5 questionsAre biodegradable packing peanuts as effective as regular ones?
Yes, biodegradable cornstarch peanuts provide the same level of protection as traditional polystyrene peanuts. They're just as effective for cushioning and protecting items during shipping.
What's the most eco-friendly packing peanut alternative?
Crumpled newspaper or shredded paper are the most eco-friendly options as they're made from recycled materials and are completely recyclable. Biodegradable cornstarch peanuts are also excellent eco-friendly choices.
Can I use regular paper instead of packing peanuts?
Yes, but you'll need to use more paper to achieve the same level of protection. Crumple or shred the paper to create air pockets that provide cushioning.
Are air pillows better than packing peanuts?
Air pillows are often better for fragile items as they provide more consistent protection and can be deflated for storage. However, they're not biodegradable like some packing peanut alternatives.
How do I dispose of biodegradable packing peanuts?
Biodegradable cornstarch peanuts can be dissolved in water or composted. They break down naturally and are safe for the environment. Regular polystyrene peanuts should be recycled through specialized programs.