Skip to content

Pheasant substitute

Best substitute

Bone-in skin-on chicken thighs, or a small whole chicken

1 small 3 lb chicken per pheasant, or 4 thighs per bird

Best for pheasant casseroles and braises

Taste and texture differ

Chicken is the substitute, and the type of chicken matters more than the amount. Use bone-in skin-on chicken thighs or a small whole chicken, not breast, because pheasant recipes almost always involve braising, pot-roasting or barding, and dark meat survives that treatment where breast does not. One 3 lb chicken replaces one pheasant, or four thighs replace one bird's worth of meat. Guinea fowl is the closest match of all if you can find it, being similarly lean with a faint gaminess. Cornish game hens are the right size for one-bird-per-person recipes. The real lesson to carry across is the opposite direction: pheasant is far leaner than chicken, so if you have a pheasant and a chicken recipe, brine it, wrap it in bacon, and take it out of the oven earlier than the recipe says, because a dry pheasant is the single most common way this bird disappoints people.

Other pheasant substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Pheasant with ratios

  1. 2Guinea fowl, also sold as guinea hen or pintade

    Close match

    Use the same amount one bird for one bird

    The closest bird you can buy, sitting exactly between chicken and pheasant in size, leanness and flavour.

    What changes
    Best for
    any pheasant recipe, roasting, braises and casseroles, French and autumn game dishes, pot roasts

    The best substitute on this list by some distance. Guinea fowl weighs two to three pounds, the same as a pheasant, is similarly lean, and has a mild gamey note of its own, so a recipe written for pheasant needs no adjustment at all beyond checking the temperature. It is a touch fattier than pheasant, which makes it a little more forgiving, and slightly milder in flavour. Look for it at butchers, farm shops and French-leaning grocers, often frozen. Like pheasant it wants barding or brining and should come out of the oven the moment it is done.

  2. 3Cornish game hens or poussin

    Taste and texture differ

    Use 1 hen for every pheasant for individual servings

    Small young chickens, the right size and shape when the recipe plates one whole bird per person.

    What changes
    Best for
    individual roasted birds, spatchcocked and grilled birds, dinner party plating, stuffed small birds, braises

    The presentation match is what you are buying here: a small bird per plate, browned and glazed, looks like the photograph in the pheasant recipe. The meat is very tender, mild and quite fatty for its size, so it is much more forgiving than pheasant and tastes distinctly of ordinary chicken with none of the nuttiness. Roast at 425F for about forty-five minutes to an hour, which is nearly the same clock as a pheasant, and bard or butter it for looks rather than out of necessity.

  3. 4Quail or partridge

    Close match

    Use 2 to 3 quail, or 1 partridge, for every pheasant portion

    The other game birds, closer in flavour than chicken and much smaller.

    What changes
    Best for
    game dishes where the gaminess is the point, roasting, quick pan-roasts, salads with game, autumn menus

    Partridge is genuinely close in character to pheasant, slightly stronger and darker, and one partridge is about half a pheasant, so allow one per person rather than one between two. Quail is tiny, at four to six ounces, so you need two or three per portion, and it cooks in fifteen to twenty minutes rather than an hour, meaning you cannot follow a pheasant recipe's timing at all. Both are leaner than chicken and share pheasant's tendency to dry out, so the same bacon-wrapping and brining advice applies with even more force.

  4. 5Rabbit

    Close match

    Use the same amount by weight; 1 rabbit replaces about 1 pheasant

    Not a bird at all, but the traditional partner to pheasant in the same recipes across Europe.

    What changes
    Best for
    braises and casseroles, cider, mustard and cream dishes, game pies, pappardelle and ragu, hunter-style stews

    A very natural swap in practice, because rabbit and pheasant appear in almost identical recipes: mustard, cider, cream, bacon, prunes, thyme. Rabbit is pale, lean and firm like pheasant and has a similarly mild, faintly nutty flavour, so the finished dish tastes remarkably close. It is bonier, which changes how you serve it, and it needs longer, generally an hour to an hour and a half of gentle braising against forty-five minutes for pheasant legs, because rabbit is all working muscle. Do not roast it dry.

  5. 6Turkey breast, the least-bad option

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by weight

    Available everywhere and the poorest choice on this list, worth naming so you know why.

    What changes
    Best for
    sliced cold game-style dishes, recipes where the bird is heavily sauced, pies and pasties

    Say it plainly: turkey breast shares pheasant's leanness, which is the property that makes pheasant difficult, and none of the properties that make it good. It is the driest option here, it tastes of turkey, and it has no gaminess at all. If it is what you have, treat it accordingly: brine it for an hour in two tablespoons of salt per quart of water, wrap it in bacon, keep it in liquid, and take it out at 160F on the dot. Turkey thigh, if you can get it, is far better than the breast for anything braised.

What is Pheasant?

Pheasant is Pheasant is a game bird, usually the ring-necked pheasant, weighing two to three pounds with pale, extremely lean meat and a mild nutty flavour that is closer to a very good chicken than to red game.

Cooking tips

  • Pheasant's entire cooking problem is that it is extremely lean, with almost no fat under the skin and none through the meat. That is why traditional recipes bard it, wrapping the breast in bacon or fat, and why they lean on cream, cider and butter. Once you understand that, both directions of substitution are easy: swapping chicken in gives you more fat and more margin for error, and swapping pheasant into a chicken recipe means adding fat and cutting time.
  • Brine a pheasant, and brine any lean bird standing in for one. Two tablespoons of salt per quart of water for two to four hours, then patted thoroughly dry, is the difference between juicy and stringy. This is a seasoning step for meat you are about to cook, kept in the fridge throughout, not a preservation method.
  • Cook the legs and the breast separately if you can, because pheasant is the extreme case of the problem every bird has. The legs are tough working muscles that want forty-five minutes to an hour of braising, and the breast is done at 155 to 160F in twenty minutes. Jointing the bird and cooking each part properly gives a better result than roasting it whole, and the same trick works with chicken standing in for it.
  • Bacon or pancetta laid over the breast, or butter pushed under the skin, is not decoration in a pheasant recipe, it is the fat the bird does not have. Keep that step even when you substitute chicken thighs, because it is contributing salt and smoky depth as well as moisture, and pheasant recipes are built around that flavour.
  • Older wild birds are much tougher than young farmed ones, and no roasting time fixes that. If you have a wild pheasant of unknown age, braise it rather than roast it: joint it, brown it, and cook it gently in cider or stock for an hour. Chicken thighs behave the same way and are the right substitute for these recipes.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best substitute for pheasant?

Guinea fowl, if you can find it, since it is nearly the same size and leanness with a similar faint gaminess and needs no adjustments at all. Otherwise use chicken, specifically bone-in skin-on thighs or a small whole bird rather than breast, at one 3 lb chicken per pheasant. Rabbit is an excellent swap in braises because it appears in almost identical recipes, and partridge is closest of all on flavour if your butcher has it.

Does pheasant taste like chicken?

Closer to chicken than to red game like venison, but not the same. The meat is pale and mild, with a firmer grain, a nutty savoury depth and a light gaminess, essentially what a chicken would taste like if it had lived outdoors and worked for a living. Farmed pheasant is milder than wild. It is much leaner than chicken, which is the difference you actually notice when cooking rather than tasting.

Can I use chicken breast instead of pheasant?

You can, but thighs are much better. Pheasant recipes are usually braises, pot-roasts or casseroles that assume the bird will sit in liquid for a while, and chicken breast turns dry and chalky under exactly those conditions. If breast is all you have, add it in the last fifteen minutes of the braise rather than at the start, and pull it at 160F.

Why did my pheasant come out dry?

Because it has almost no fat, so there is nothing to protect it once the internal temperature climbs past about 160F. Three fixes, in order of usefulness: brine it for two to four hours beforehand, lay bacon or pancetta over the breast while it cooks, and take it off the heat earlier than you think, at 155 to 160F in the breast, then rest it ten minutes. Braising the legs separately from the breast solves the problem entirely.

Can I just leave the pheasant out?

Not really, because in a pheasant recipe the bird is the dish. What you can do is keep everything else, since the cider, cream, mustard, bacon, mushrooms, thyme and prunes that surround pheasant are the real character of these recipes, and put chicken thighs, rabbit or even large flat mushrooms in the bird's place. A mushroom and cider braise with the same seasonings is genuinely good, just not a game dish.

Related substitutes

More meat & protein substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore meat & protein