Skip to content

Pearl Sugar substitute

Best substitute

Crushed sugar cubes

Use the same amount by volume as the pearl sugar you are replacing

Best for chouquettes

Close match

Pearl sugar's job is texture and appearance, not overall sweetness: it stays as visible crunchy nuggets or, in the coarse Belgian grade, melts into caramel pockets inside the dough. For sprinkling on top of chouquettes, brioche, muffins or scones, use coarse sanding sugar or crushed sugar cubes at 1:1. Crushed sugar cubes are the free option and look almost identical, so put a few cubes in a zip bag and hit them once or twice with a rolling pin to get 3 to 4mm chunks rather than powder. For Liege waffles, roughly crushed sugar cubes are the only common swap that works, because granulated sugar just dissolves and sweetens the whole batter.

Other pearl sugar substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Pearl Sugar with ratios

  1. 2Coarse sanding sugar or decorating sugar

    Different texture

    Use the same amount by volume, for toppings only

    Large clear crystals sold for decorating, designed to survive the oven without melting.

    What changes
    Best for
    muffins, scones, cookies, sweet buns, danishes

    Holds up perfectly on top of a bake, but it sparkles rather than sitting as opaque white lumps, and the crystals are much smaller, so you get sparkle and a fine crunch instead of distinct nuggets. Useless folded into waffle dough, where the pieces need to be large enough to caramelise into pockets.

  2. 3Turbinado or demerara sugar

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume, toppings only

    Large golden raw-sugar crystals with some molasses still attached.

    What changes
    Best for
    scones, muffins, crumble toppings, coffee cake, sweet breads

    Holds up well in the oven and adds a faint caramel note, which is often an improvement. Visually quite different, amber and glassy rather than opaque white, and the crystals partly dissolve into the crust, giving a thin caramel glaze rather than crunchy white pearls. Excellent on scones.

  3. 4Rock sugar or Scandinavian hail sugar

    Close match

    Use the same amount

    Large white sugar lumps sold under other names in Asian, Scandinavian and Belgian grocers.

    What changes
    Best for
    chouquettes, brioche, Liege waffles, buns, cardamom buns

    Frequently the identical product with a different label, so if you find large white sugar lumps sold as rock sugar or hail sugar, crush them to 4 or 5mm and you have pearl sugar. Check the crystals are not so hard they are unpleasant to bite; some rock sugar is glassy rather than compressed.

  4. 5Homemade pearl sugar

    Close match

    1 cup granulated sugar plus 2 tbsp water makes about ¾ cup

    Stir sugar with just enough water to make a thick barely-damp paste, press it flat on a lined tray, dry at 250F for 30 to 40 minutes, then break it up and sift.

    What changes
    Best for
    chouquettes, brioche, Liege waffles, scones, muffins

    Genuinely works and costs pennies. The lumps come out more irregular and slightly crumblier than commercial pearl sugar, so they crush more easily under your fingers, but they behave the same in the oven. Sift out the fine powder or it will just dissolve into the crust.

  5. 6Granulated sugar

    Different texture

    Use the same amount but expect a different result

    The last resort, and worth understanding before you use it.

    What changes
    Best for
    topping muffins, topping sweet buns

    It dissolves, which is the one thing pearl sugar is designed not to do. On top of a chouquette it becomes a thin sticky glaze rather than crunchy nuggets. In a Liege waffle it sweetens the whole dough evenly and gives no caramel pockets at all, which is most of the point of the waffle. Crush sugar cubes instead if you possibly can.

What is Pearl Sugar?

Pearl Sugar is Pearl sugar, also sold as nib sugar, hail sugar, sucre perle or Belgian pearl sugar, is sugar pressed into hard opaque white lumps that hold their shape in a hot oven instead of melting.

Cooking tips

  • Pearl sugar's job is texture, not sweetness. It is meant to stay in visible crunchy lumps, so anything that dissolves in the oven, including granulated, caster and powdered sugar, is not doing the same job no matter how much you use.
  • There are two grades and they are not interchangeable. Fine Swedish or French pearl sugar, around 2 to 3mm, is for sprinkling on buns and chouquettes. Coarse Belgian pearl sugar, around 5 to 8mm, is for folding into Liege waffle dough where the big lumps melt into caramel.
  • Crush sugar cubes with restraint. One or two firm taps in a zip-top bag, then tip the pieces into a sieve and shake the powder out. Powder dissolves and gets you nothing, so sifting is not optional.
  • Press the sugar into the dough rather than just scattering it. Pearl sugar bounces off dry surfaces, so brush with egg wash or a little milk first and press the pearls on lightly with your fingertips so they are still there after baking.
  • Any sugar that touches a hot waffle iron caramelises and sticks. Fold pearl sugar or crushed cubes into Liege dough and keep it away from the surface, and expect to clean the iron more carefully than usual.

Frequently asked questions

What can I use instead of pearl sugar?

Crushed sugar cubes are the closest and cheapest, and the only common swap that also works inside Liege waffle dough. Coarse sanding sugar is a good topping substitute, and turbinado works too if you do not mind an amber colour and a faint caramel flavour.

Can I just leave pearl sugar out?

On a brioche, bun or muffin, yes. You lose a crunchy sweet topping but the bake itself is unaffected, and a sprinkle of turbinado or a light glaze fills the gap. In a Liege waffle you cannot, because the caramelised sugar pockets are what makes it a Liege waffle rather than just a sweet waffle.

Is pearl sugar the same as sanding sugar?

No. Pearl sugar is opaque white compressed lumps that stay whole in the oven. Sanding sugar is large clear crystals that sparkle and are considerably smaller. Sanding sugar is a decent topping substitute and a poor one inside dough, where the pieces are too small to caramelise into pockets.

Can I make pearl sugar at home?

Yes, and it works well. Mix a cup of granulated sugar with about two tablespoons of water until it feels like damp sand, press it into a slab on a lined tray, dry it in a 250F oven for 30 to 40 minutes, then break it up and sift out the powder. The lumps are more irregular than shop-bought but behave the same.

Why did my pearl sugar disappear in the oven?

Either it was actually granulated or sanding sugar, which dissolves, or the dough was very wet or baked slowly enough for the sugar to melt into it. Press the pearls onto the surface just before baking, or use the coarser grade, which survives longer.

How much pearl sugar do I need for chouquettes?

About a third of a cup for a batch of 20 to 24, sprinkled generously and pressed onto the egg-washed tops. Some will fall off in the oven, so scatter more than looks necessary and expect to lose a little.

Related substitutes

More sweeteners substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore sweeteners