Mojo Sauce substitute
Homemade Mojo Criollo (five-minute version)
Use the same amount as the mojo sauce you are replacing
For 1 cup, whisk 1/2 cup orange juice, 1/4 cup lime juice, 6 to 8 crushed garlic cloves, 1 teaspoon dried oregano, 1 teaspoon toasted ground cumin, 1/3 cup olive oil and 1 teaspoon salt. Because the missing ingredient people usually cannot buy is sour orange rather than mojo itself, the orange-and-lime blend at roughly two to one is the standard, well-established stand-in and tastes correct.
Other mojo sauce substitutes
Ranked, with the exact amount to use
Substitutes for Mojo Sauce with ratios
2Chimichurri
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- standing in for mojo verde, grilled meat and fish, potatoes and vegetables, drizzling over a finished dish
Stir in a handful of chopped cilantro and a squeeze of lime to push it toward mojo verde. Cut the chile flakes if your recipe is not meant to be hot.
3Harissa Thinned with Oil and Vinegar
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- papas arrugadas and boiled potatoes, dipping sauce for grilled meat, spooning over roasted vegetables, quick substitution
Taste as you go. If it is too hot, add a spoonful of jarred roasted red pepper to soften the heat and push it sweeter and more Spanish.
4Romesco or Roasted Red Pepper and Garlic Sauce
Taste and texture differWhat changes
- Best for
- papas arrugadas, grilled fish and vegetables, as a table sauce, sandwiches
Thin it with 1 tablespoon olive oil and 2 teaspoons vinegar per 1/2 cup until it pours. Ajvar from a jar works the same way and is cheaper.
5Sofrito plus Vinegar
Taste and texture differWhat changes
- Best for
- stews and braises, beans and rice, seasoning cooked dishes, when you already have sofrito in the freezer
Not a substitute for mojo used raw on a plate. Add the vinegar or lime juice off the heat at the end so it keeps its brightness.
6Garlic, Olive Oil, Lime and Cumin (least-bad emergency version)
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- last-minute pork or chicken marinade, grilled vegetables, seasoning boiled potatoes, when the pantry is bare
Honest expectation: it lacks the depth and fruitiness of real mojo. If you have any orange juice or a pinch of dried oregano, add them and it improves markedly.
What is Mojo Sauce?
Mojo Sauce is a family of loose garlic-and-oil sauces from the Canary Islands and the Spanish-speaking Caribbean, spooned over grilled meat, fish and potatoes or used as a marinade, and whichever version you meet - red mojo picon built on dried peppers, cumin and vinegar, green mojo verde built on cilantro or parsley, or Cuban mojo criollo built on sour orange juice - its job is raw garlic punch plus sharp acid.
Cooking tips
- The ingredient people usually cannot find is not the mojo, it is the sour orange, called naranja agria or Seville orange. Orange juice mixed with lime juice at roughly two parts to one is the accepted stand-in and works in every mojo criollo recipe.
- Mojo rojo should pour, not sit. Canarian papas arrugadas need a sauce loose enough to run into the cracked skin of the potato, so if your sauce looks like a paste, thin it with oil and vinegar until it drips off a spoon.
- Raw garlic mojo turns bitter and harsh after about a day in the fridge. Either use it within twenty four hours, or warm the crushed garlic gently in the oil for a minute before combining, which mellows it and buys you several days.
- Do not marinate pork or chicken in mojo for much longer than about eight hours if the pieces are small, because the citrus acid firms and then makes the outer layer mealy. A whole shoulder can take overnight because the acid barely penetrates a large roast.
- Toast and grind your cumin rather than shaking it out of an old jar. Cumin is the flavor that makes mojo taste Canarian rather than just garlicky, and it fades faster than almost any other spice.
Frequently asked questions
Can I just leave the mojo out?
What is the difference between mojo rojo, mojo verde and mojo criollo?
Is bottled mojo as good as homemade?
Can I use Italian dressing or a citrus vinaigrette instead?
How long does homemade mojo keep?
Related substitutes
More sauces & condiments substitutes