Skip to content

Soy Curls substitute

Best substitute

Textured Vegetable Protein (TVP) Strips or Chunks

Use the same amount by dry weight as the soy curls you are replacing

Best for stir-fries

Different texture

Textured vegetable protein strips or chunks are the closest swap at 1:1 by dry weight, rehydrated in hot broth. Torn seitan works if you want more chew and are not avoiding gluten, and extra-firm tofu that has been frozen, thawed and pressed shreds convincingly and drinks up marinade. Whatever you use, rehydrate it in seasoned broth rather than water, because soy curls have essentially no flavour of their own.

Other soy curls substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Soy Curls with ratios

  1. 2Soya Chunks or Soya Nuggets (Indian Groceries)

    Different texture

    Use the same amount by dry weight

    The same extruded soy protein sold under a different name and usually far cheaper.

    What changes
    Best for
    curries, stews, biryani, stir-fries

    Functionally identical to TVP chunks. They are denser and rounder than soy curls, so pieces read more like meatballs than shreds. Boil 5 minutes rather than just soaking, then squeeze out the water twice, which removes the raw-soy smell they sometimes have.

  2. 3Seitan, Torn into Strips

    Taste and texture differ

    Use 6-8 oz seitan for every 1 cup dry soy curls

    Cooked wheat gluten, dense and genuinely chewy.

    What changes
    Best for
    stir-fries, fajitas, barbecue, sandwiches, braises

    Chewier and denser than soy curls, with a distinct wheaty savour rather than a neutral one, and it browns beautifully. Tear it rather than cutting so the edges catch and crisp. Not gluten-free, and not an option for anyone avoiding wheat.

  3. 4Extra-Firm Tofu, Frozen, Thawed and Torn

    Different texture

    Use One 14 oz block for every 1.5 cups dry soy curls

    Freezing rebuilds tofu's texture into something spongy and shreddable.

    What changes
    Best for
    stir-fries, curries, braises, sandwiches, sheet-pan dishes

    Freeze the block solid, thaw it, then squeeze out the water and tear it into rough pieces. The resulting sponge soaks up marinade the way soy curls do and browns well, but the bite is softer and it lacks the long fibrous pull. Cheap, easy to find and genuinely good.

  4. 5Shredded King Oyster or Oyster Mushrooms

    Different taste

    Use About 1 lb fresh for every 1 cup dry soy curls

    Mushroom stems pulled into strands, which mimic shredded meat closely.

    What changes
    Best for
    pulled barbecue, tacos, sandwiches, stir-fries

    Texturally excellent and better than any soy product at looking like pulled meat, but the flavour is unmistakably mushroom and the protein content is a fraction of soy curls. Dry-fry them first to drive off water, then sauce them.

  5. 6Young Green Jackfruit in Brine

    Different taste

    Use One 20 oz can for every 1 cup dry soy curls

    Unripe jackfruit, which shreds apart into stringy pieces.

    What changes
    Best for
    pulled barbecue, tacos, carnitas-style dishes

    It shreds convincingly and takes on sauce well, but it is a fruit: expect a faint sweet-tart note, and expect almost no protein, so this is a texture swap rather than a nutritional one. Drain, rinse, squeeze dry and dry-fry before saucing, or it stays watery.

What is Soy Curls?

Soy Curls is Soy curls, sold almost exclusively as Butler Soy Curls, are dehydrated strips of whole cooked soybeans that rehydrate in hot liquid into chewy, shreddable pieces used in place of chicken.

Cooking tips

  • Rehydrate in hot broth, never plain water. Soy curls and every substitute here are near-flavourless carriers, and the soak is your one chance to get seasoning into the middle of each piece. Vegetable or mushroom broth with a splash of soy sauce works for almost anything.
  • Squeeze them dry, hard, before they hit the pan. A soaked piece that is still full of liquid steams instead of browning, and browning is where the chewy, meaty exterior comes from. Wring them out in a clean towel or press them between two plates.
  • Rough proportions to plan around: 1 cup of dry soy curls rehydrates to roughly 2 cups, about the volume of 8 ounces of cooked chicken. A whole 8-ounce bag serves four generously.
  • They scorch faster than meat because of residual sugars in the soybean, so use medium-high rather than screaming heat and keep them moving. Once they go past deep brown they turn bitter, not crispy.
  • For barbecue or fajita dishes, sauce them after browning, not before. Sugar in the sauce burns long before the pieces have taken any colour, and sauced-then-fried soy curls end up sticky and pale.

Frequently asked questions

What is the closest substitute for soy curls?

Textured vegetable protein in strip or chunk form, at 1:1 by dry weight. It uses the same rehydrate-squeeze-brown method and behaves almost the same in the pan. The differences are that TVP is made from defatted soy flour so it tastes blander, and it is a little spongier and less stringy.

Are soy curls the same as TVP?

Not quite. Soy curls are made from whole soybeans, so they keep the bean's fat and a bit more flavour and a more fibrous pull. TVP is extruded from defatted soy flour. They are close enough to substitute freely, and TVP is far easier to buy.

Can I use tofu instead of soy curls?

Yes, but freeze it first. Freeze an extra-firm block solid, thaw it, squeeze out the water and tear it into pieces. That gives you a spongy, marinade-hungry texture much closer to rehydrated soy curls than fresh tofu, which is smooth and breaks rather than shreds.

Can I just leave soy curls out?

Only if the dish has another substantial protein in it. Soy curls are usually the entire protein component and the main source of chew, so leaving them out gives you a bowl of sauce and vegetables. Chickpeas or white beans are a reasonable fallback if all you need is protein and you do not care about the shredded texture.

How much does a cup of dry soy curls make?

About 2 cups rehydrated, which is roughly what 8 ounces of cooked chicken would give you. Plan on a quarter cup dry per person as a rough serving, or a little more if the soy curls are the centrepiece.

Related substitutes

More meat & protein substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore meat & protein