Skip to content

Petai substitute

Best substitute

Frozen or vacuum-packed petai

Use the same amount use straight from frozen as the petai you are replacing

Best for sambal petai

Close match

Be honest with yourself about which half of petai you need. For the waxy, dense, almost-crunchy bite that survives a hot wok, double-podded broad beans (fava beans) are the closest thing, and frozen shelled edamame is the easiest to find. But neither gives you the sulphurous, garlicky, faintly bitter smell, and that smell is the entire reason petai is in the dish. Petai's job is aroma plus bitterness plus texture, not bulk or protein. If you can find frozen or vacuum-packed petai in an Asian freezer cabinet, buy that instead of any bean, because it is genuinely close to fresh. If you cannot, use broad beans for the texture and stir two finely chopped raw garlic cloves in at the very end for a hint of the pungency, and accept that you are making a very good sambal goreng rather than sambal petai.

Other petai substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Petai with ratios

  1. 2Broad beans (fava beans), double-podded

    Different taste

    Use the same amount by volume

    Fresh or frozen broad beans, blanched 60 seconds and slipped out of their tough grey skins.

    What changes
    Best for
    sambal petai, stir-fries, curries, matching the texture and the look

    The best texture match by a wide margin: the same flat kidney shape and the same dense waxy yield rather than a starchy squash. What is completely missing is the sulphur. A sambal made with broad beans tastes clean, faintly sweet and nutty instead of pungent and bitter, so it reads as a pleasant vegetable sambal rather than the confrontational dish petai makes. Stir two finely chopped raw garlic cloves and a pinch of salt in off the heat per cup of beans to get some allium bite back.

  2. 3Frozen shelled edamame

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume

    Young green soybeans, sold shelled and frozen in most large supermarkets.

    What changes
    Best for
    stir-fries, fried rice, sambal, when you need something today

    The most findable option. Edamame is rounder, sweeter and snappier, so it pops between the teeth rather than yielding waxily, and the sambal comes out noticeably sweet and mild. Cook it no more than two minutes from frozen or it goes mealy. Because it is sweeter than petai, pull back slightly on the palm sugar in your sambal and push the tamarind and shrimp paste up.

  3. 4Lima beans or butter beans, fresh or frozen

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume

    Broad flat pale-green beans that look closer to petai on the plate than almost anything else.

    What changes
    Best for
    sambal, braises, dishes where petai is one component among several

    Visually the best match, and cheap. The trade is texture: limas are softer, creamier and much more starchy, so they break down at the edges and thicken your sambal into something closer to a paste. Add them in the last minute only, and skip canned ones entirely, because they collapse into mush the moment they hit a hot pan.

  4. 5Jengkol (dogfruit)

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount but boil it first

    The other Indonesian stinky bean, from a different tree entirely, sold frozen or in brine.

    What changes
    Best for
    sambal, semur jengkol, when the pungency matters more than the exact texture

    If your shop has jengkol but not petai, you have the aroma problem solved. Jengkol is even more sulphurous and more aggressively funky, and it is much denser and starchier, closer to a waxy potato than a bean. It needs 30 to 45 minutes of boiling before it becomes edible, often with a change of water, so plan ahead. Not the same ingredient, but it lands in the same emotional place.

  5. 6Garlic chives (kucai) or thinly sliced raw garlic, as an aroma patch

    Taste and texture differ

    Use ¼ cup chopped for every cup of petai called for

    An allium hit stirred in at the end, used alongside one of the textural beans above rather than on its own.

    What changes
    Best for
    closing the flavour gap on a broad bean or edamame sambal, nasi goreng, noodle stir-fries

    This is a repair, not a substitute. It gives you pungency and a green sulphurous edge that no bean provides, but zero waxy texture, so pair it with broad beans or edamame. Add it off the heat or in the final 30 seconds; cooked garlic turns sweet and loses exactly the raw sharpness you are borrowing it for.

What is Petai?

Petai is a bright green, flat, waxy bean from the long twisted seed pods of the Parkia speciosa tree, sold across Southeast Asia as pete, sator, twisted cluster bean, bitter bean or stink bean, and valued as much for its pungent sulphurous aroma as for its firm, slightly bitter bite.

Cooking tips

  • Frozen petai is the answer, not a bean. Vacuum-packed pods or shelled beans from an Asian freezer cabinet cost little, keep for months and lose barely any texture. Use them straight from frozen without thawing, or they weep and go slack.
  • Add petai late. Slide it into a sambal in the last two or three minutes so it stays waxy and the aroma stays bright and volatile. Long simmering makes it soft, grey-green and dully bitter, which is the worst version of it.
  • If you are using broad beans as the stand-in, double-pod them: blanch 60 seconds, then slip off the leathery grey skin with your thumbnail. Skip this and the sambal has a chewy, papery mouthfeel that reads as badly cooked rather than authentic.
  • Petai's bitterness only works because of what sits against it. Palm sugar, shrimp paste and tamarind are the three things holding a sambal petai together, and you should keep all three at full strength even when the bean changes, because a substitute bean is milder and needs less competition, not more.
  • The strong smell in your urine for a day or so after eating petai is normal and harmless. It comes from sulphur compounds in the bean, and jengkol does the same thing, more so.

Frequently asked questions

Can I just leave petai out?

Yes, and in most dishes that is the better call than a bad swap. Petai does no structural job at all, so a sambal goreng, nasi goreng or prawn stir-fry made without it still works completely and still tastes good. What you lose is the pungent, bitter, sulphurous bite that gives the dish its name and its whole character. If petai is a minor component, leave it out. If the dish is called sambal petai, understand that you are cooking something different and enjoy it on its own terms.

What is the closest substitute for stink beans?

For texture, double-podded broad beans, then frozen edamame, then fresh or frozen lima beans. For the smell, nothing in a normal supermarket comes close. Jengkol is the only common ingredient with a comparable sulphurous funk, and it is a different bean with a much denser, starchier texture. The honest answer is that petai's aroma has no substitute and that you should decide whether you are chasing the texture or the smell before you shop.

Are petai, pete, sator and stink beans all the same thing?

Yes. Petai is the Malay and Indonesian name, pete is a common Indonesian spelling, sator is the Thai name, and in English it is sold as stink bean, bitter bean or twisted cluster bean. They are all Parkia speciosa, and any recipe using one of those names is asking for the same ingredient.

Is petai the same as jengkol?

No. They are both famously pungent Southeast Asian beans, but jengkol comes from a different tree (Archidendron pauciflorum), and it is rounder, harder and much starchier. Jengkol needs long boiling before it can be eaten, sometimes with a water change, while petai is ready with a couple of minutes in a pan. Jengkol is also stronger smelling than petai, which is saying something.

Can I use canned or jarred petai in brine?

Yes, and it is a reasonable pantry option. Rinse it thoroughly under cold water, then add it at the very end or off the heat, because it is already fully cooked and soft. Expect it noticeably softer and saltier than fresh, so reduce the salt or shrimp paste in your sambal and taste before you add any more.

Related substitutes

More legumes substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore legumes