Skip to content

Kaniwa substitute

Best substitute

Quinoa, ideally red or black

Use the same amount by volume, same 1:2 water ratio, same 15 minutes as the kaniwa you are replacing

Best for grain salads

Different texture

Quinoa is the best substitute at 1:1 by volume with the same water ratio and cooking time, though it must be rinsed and it fluffs up rather than staying poppy and crunchy. Amaranth matches kaniwa's tiny scale and nutty flavour at 1:1 but turns creamy and porridge-like, so use it for breakfast bowls rather than salads. Teff works the same way. For a grain salad where you want separate seeds, red or black quinoa is the closest.

Other kaniwa substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Kaniwa with ratios

  1. 2Amaranth

    Different texture

    Use the same amount by volume, but reduce liquid to 1:1.5

    Almost exactly the same seed size as kaniwa with a comparable nutty, faintly peppery flavour, and no rinsing needed.

    What changes
    Best for
    porridge, breakfast bowls, thickening soups, baking

    Amaranth goes gluey and creamy as it cooks, so a grain salad made with it clumps into a single mass. Use it where you want that creaminess and cut the liquid, or toast it first and use it as a crunchy topping instead.

  2. 3Teff

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume

    The same tiny scale and a similar poppy mouthfeel, with an earthier flavour that reads as molasses and cocoa rather than nut.

    What changes
    Best for
    porridge, baking, thickening, breakfast

    Muddier and darker-tasting than kaniwa, and it also thickens into a soft mass rather than staying separate. Excellent in a hot cereal, wrong in a cold salad.

  3. 4Millet, toasted first

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume

    Cooks up into separate grains the way kaniwa does, which most tiny seeds do not, and toasting it dry in the pan first develops the nuttiness kaniwa has naturally.

    What changes
    Best for
    grain salads, pilafs, side dishes, stuffings

    Larger, fluffier and mild to the point of blandness, with a corn-like sweetness. Toast it for three minutes in a dry pan until it smells nutty or the dish tastes flat next to kaniwa.

  4. 5Fine bulgur or couscous

    Different taste

    Use the same amount by volume

    Gives the small-grain mouthfeel and is faster to prepare than anything else here, since fine bulgur only needs soaking in hot water.

    What changes
    Best for
    grain salads, tabbouleh-style dishes, quick sides

    Wheat-based, so not gluten-free, which matters since gluten-free eating is why many people buy kaniwa. Also much blander. Stir in a spoonful of toasted seeds for the nutty edge kaniwa brings on its own.

  5. 6Toasted buckwheat groats (kasha)

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume

    Similarly dense and chewy rather than fluffy, and strongly nutty, so it holds up in a salad the way kaniwa does.

    What changes
    Best for
    grain salads, pilafs, side dishes

    Much larger and considerably more assertive, with an earthy, almost roasted flavour that will dominate a delicate dressing. Cook it just until tender, since it goes to mush quickly once it passes that point.

What is Kaniwa?

Kaniwa is Kaniwa, also spelled canihua or canahua and marketed as baby quinoa, is a tiny reddish-brown Andean seed from Chenopodium pallidicaule, a close cousin of quinoa that is about half its size and naturally free of bitter saponins.

Cooking tips

  • Do not rinse kaniwa. Unlike quinoa it has no bitter saponin coating, so rinsing does nothing except wash seeds down the drain, and the seeds are small enough to pass through most sieves. If you are substituting quinoa in the other direction, you absolutely must rinse it.
  • Toast it dry in a hot pan for two minutes before adding water. Kaniwa is already nutty and toasting doubles it, and it also helps the seeds stay separate rather than clumping. This one step is the difference between a memorable bowl and a dull one.
  • Use one part kaniwa to two parts water, simmer covered for about fifteen minutes, then rest off the heat for five. Drain through a fine-mesh sieve or a piece of muslin if there is liquid left, since a standard colander will lose the lot.
  • Kaniwa never fluffs. It stays dense and slightly crunchy, closer to a bowl of poppy seeds than to a bowl of quinoa, and that texture is the main reason people seek it out. Any substitute that fluffs, including quinoa, gives you a lighter dish, so if crunch is what you want, scatter toasted seeds over the top.
  • Stir a quarter of the flour weight of kaniwa flour, or a couple of tablespoons of whole toasted kaniwa, into cookie and bread doughs for a nutty crunch. Whole seeds stay crunchy through baking where quinoa softens, so this is one use where the substitutes genuinely underperform.

Frequently asked questions

Can I just leave kaniwa out?

Only if it is a topping or one grain in a mixed blend, in which case nothing much is lost. If it is the base of a salad or a bowl, you need something in its place, and an equal volume of quinoa is a genuinely good replacement rather than a compromise.

Is kaniwa the same as quinoa?

No, but they are close cousins from the same genus and the same part of the Andes. Kaniwa is about half the size, darker reddish-brown, naturally saponin-free so it needs no rinsing, and it stays dense and crunchy where quinoa fluffs. The baby quinoa marketing name refers to the size, not to immature quinoa.

Do I need to rinse kaniwa?

No. Kaniwa does not carry the bitter saponin coating that makes rinsing essential for quinoa, and the seeds are so fine that most sieves will not hold them anyway. Skip the rinse and go straight to toasting.

What does kaniwa taste like?

Nuttier and less grassy than quinoa, with a mild toasted flavour and no bitterness at all. The texture is as distinctive as the taste: tiny seeds that stay slightly crunchy and pop between the teeth rather than going soft and fluffy.

Is kaniwa gluten-free?

Yes. Like quinoa and amaranth it is a seed rather than a cereal grain, so it contains no gluten. If you are substituting for that reason, avoid bulgur and couscous on this list, since both are wheat, and stick to quinoa, amaranth, teff, millet or buckwheat.

Related substitutes

More grains & starches substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore grains & starches