What Potato to Substitute for Yukon Gold

Yukon Gold Potato substitute

Russet Potatoes

Use the same amount as the yukon gold potato you are replacing

Best for baking

Close match

To substitute for Yukon Gold potatoes, use russet potatoes for baking and mashing, red potatoes for roasting and salads, or white potatoes for general cooking. Yellow potatoes are the closest match and work in most applications.

Compare all 6 yukon gold potato substitutes

Learn what potato to substitute for Yukon Gold potatoes. Get expert recommendations for russet, red, white, and other potato varieties that work perfectly in recipes calling for Yukon Gold potatoes.

Other yukon gold potato substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

2Red Potatoes
Different texture
Use the same amount
Small, waxy potatoes that are highly recommended for dishes where you want the potatoes to maintain their shape
What changes
Best for
roasting, salads, boiling, soups, stews, side dishes
Recommended for roasting and salads, waxy texture holds shape well
3White Potatoes
Close match
Use the same amount
Medium-starch potatoes that are one of the best all-purpose recommendations for substituting Yukon Gold potatoes
What changes
Best for
general cooking, roasting, mashing, soups, stews, fries
Excellent all-purpose recommendation with similar texture and flavor
4Yellow Potatoes
Close match
Use the same amount
Yellow-fleshed potatoes that are the closest match to Yukon Gold potatoes, making them the top recommendation for most recipes
What changes
Best for
general cooking, roasting, mashing, soups, stews, fries
Closest match to Yukon Gold, recommended for most applications
5Fingerling Potatoes
Different texture
Use the same amount
Small, elongated potatoes that are recommended for roasting and elegant presentations, though they're smaller than Yukon Gold
What changes
Best for
roasting, salads, side dishes, appetizers, special occasions
Recommended for roasting and special presentations, smaller size

How it behaves in this recipe

When choosing what potato to substitute for Yukon Gold, consider the cooking method and desired outcome. Yukon Gold potatoes have medium-starch content and yellow flesh, making them versatile. Recommendations vary by use: russet for baking/mashing, red for roasting/salads, yellow for closest overall match, and white for general cooking.

Cooking tips

For baking and mashing, russet potatoes are the top recommendation
For roasting and salads, red potatoes are highly recommended
For general cooking, white potatoes are an excellent recommendation
For the closest match overall, yellow potatoes are the best recommendation
For elegant presentations, fingerling potatoes are recommended
Choose potatoes of similar size for even cooking when substituting
Adjust cooking times as different varieties may cook at different rates
Consider the final dish when choosing your recommended substitute

Notes on yukon gold potato

Consider mixing different recommended varieties for varied texture
Choose based on your specific cooking method and desired result
Try different recommendations to find your personal preference
Use seasonal availability to guide your choice of recommended substitute

Frequently asked questions

What potato should I substitute for Yukon Gold?

For most applications, russet potatoes are the best substitute for Yukon Gold. For roasting and salads, red potatoes are recommended. For the closest match overall, yellow potatoes are the top choice.

Which potato is recommended as the best substitute for Yukon Gold?

Yellow potatoes are recommended as the best substitute for Yukon Gold because they have identical characteristics. Russet potatoes are recommended for baking and mashing, while red potatoes are recommended for roasting and salads.

What potato do chefs recommend for substituting Yukon Gold?

Chefs typically recommend russet potatoes for baking and mashing, red potatoes for roasting and salads, and yellow potatoes for the closest overall match. The choice depends on the specific cooking method and desired texture.

What's the recommended substitute for Yukon Gold in mashed potatoes?

Russet potatoes are the recommended substitute for Yukon Gold in mashed potatoes because they have similar starch content and create a creamy texture when mashed.

What potato is recommended for substituting Yukon Gold in roasted dishes?

Red potatoes are recommended for substituting Yukon Gold in roasted dishes because they hold their shape well and develop a nice crispy exterior when roasted.

Other yukon gold potato substitutes

2Red Potatoes

3White Potatoes

4Yellow Potatoes

5Fingerling Potatoes