Skip to content

Serra da Estrela Cheese substitute

Best substitute

Torta del Casar or Queso de la Serena

Use the same amount as the serra da estrela cheese you are replacing

Best for spooning onto bread

Close match

If you can find Spanish Torta del Casar or Queso de la Serena, buy it: they are made the same way from the same kind of milk with the same thistle coagulant and they are a genuine one-for-one swap. Otherwise a very ripe Brie or Camembert served at room temperature gives you the right spoonable texture and washed-rind aroma, though it is cow's milk so it tastes mushroomier and less sweet. Young Azeitao or Queijo de Nisa are the Portuguese cousins if a Portuguese grocer is within reach.

Other serra da estrela cheese substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Serra da Estrela Cheese with ratios

  1. 2Very Ripe Brie or Camembert

    Different taste

    Use the same amount

    A soft washed or bloomy rind cheese, left out of the fridge for at least an hour so the paste slumps, giving you the same spoon-it-onto-bread experience from a supermarket.

    What changes
    Best for
    cheese boards, spreading on rustic bread, warm baked cheese, serving with quince paste

    The texture is the match here, not the flavour. Cow's milk makes it distinctly mushroomy, buttery and barnyardy where Serra da Estrela is sweet, grassy and mineral, and there is no thistle bitterness at all. A drizzle of honey and a few drops of good olive oil close a surprising amount of that gap. Buy the ripest one in the case and let it sit out.

  2. 3Young Azeitao or Queijo de Nisa

    Close match

    Use the same amount

    Two other Portuguese thistle-set sheep's milk cheeses, made in smaller wheels near Lisbon and in the Alentejo respectively.

    What changes
    Best for
    everything Serra da Estrela is used for, cheese boards, bread and cheese, Portuguese menus

    Effectively interchangeable, which is why Portuguese recipes often list them together. Azeitao comes in small pucks and is usually a touch saltier and more pungent; Nisa is firmer and a little more acidic. Both are available from Portuguese and Brazilian grocers in North America far more often than Serra da Estrela is.

  3. 4Soft Young Sheep's Milk Cheese (Perail, Brebirousse, Robiola)

    Close match

    Use the same amount

    Small-format soft cheeses made from sheep's milk, or from mixed sheep and cow's milk, which get the milk right even when the technique differs.

    What changes
    Best for
    cheese boards, spreading, warm on toast, serving with cured meats

    These nail the sweet, faintly woolly sheep's milk flavour that Brie cannot, which is arguably the more important half of Serra da Estrela. They are milder and less savoury than the real thing and lack its slightly bitter finish, so add a pinch of flaky salt and serve with something assertive alongside, such as olives or a slice of jamon.

  4. 5Whipped Goat Cheese or Sheep Ricotta Loosened With Cream

    Different taste

    Use 1 cup cheese + 2 tbsp heavy cream for every 1 cup Serra da Estrela

    Fresh goat cheese or sheep's milk ricotta beaten with cream until it is smooth and spoonable, seasoned with salt and olive oil.

    What changes
    Best for
    cooking, filling pastries, stirring into warm dishes, spreading when no aged cheese is available

    Use this only when the cheese is going into something rather than onto a board. You get the spoonable consistency and, with sheep ricotta, the right milk, but no rind aroma, no aged depth and none of the savoury bitterness. It tastes noticeably fresher, more acidic and simpler. Add a little salt, because both are much less salty than a matured cheese.

  5. 6Manchego or Pecorino (For Aged Serra da Estrela)

    Different texture

    Use the same amount

    Firm sheep's milk cheeses to use when your recipe calls for Serra da Estrela Velho, the aged version, which is dry and hard rather than spoonable.

    What changes
    Best for
    grating, slicing for boards, melting into soups, cooked dishes

    Worth knowing that Serra da Estrela exists in two forms. If the recipe says velho or amanteigado matters to it, check which one it means, because using a hard grating cheese in place of a spoonable one, or the reverse, is the mistake that actually ruins a dish. Manchego curado is the best all-round match for the aged version; Pecorino is saltier and sharper, so use about three quarters as much.

What is Serra da Estrela Cheese?

Serra da Estrela Cheese is Queijo Serra da Estrela is a raw sheep's milk cheese from Portugal's Serra da Estrela mountains that is set with cardoon thistle instead of animal rennet and aged only a month or two, which leaves the inside so soft that you cut a lid off the rind and eat the paste with a spoon.

Cooking tips

  • Take it out of the fridge at least an hour before serving, and two hours if the kitchen is cool. Serra da Estrela and every soft substitute for it are stiff and mute when cold; the paste only slumps and the aroma only opens up at room temperature.
  • Serve it the traditional way: cut a circular lid off the top rind with a small knife, fold it back, and spoon the paste straight onto bread, using the rind as a bowl. Portuguese broa, a dense corn and rye bread, is the classic partner because it can take the weight.
  • If your substitute is under-ripe and stubbornly firm in the middle, leave it wrapped in its paper on the counter for a day or two. Soft cheeses keep ripening from the rind inward, and a Camembert that was chalky on Monday can be spoonable by Wednesday.
  • Do not melt thistle-set cheeses into a sauce. The enzymes and the very soft protein structure that make them spoonable also make them prone to going grainy and splitting into oil when heated hard. Use them as a finishing cheese, spooned over hot potatoes or vegetables off the heat.
  • Pair it with something that cuts the fat: a dry Portuguese red, a glass of dry sherry, quince paste, or honey and walnuts. The cheese is rich and slightly bitter, and it wants either acid or sweetness beside it.

Frequently asked questions

What is the closest substitute for Serra da Estrela cheese?

Spanish Torta del Casar or Queso de la Serena, because they are made by the same method: raw sheep's milk set with cardoon thistle and matured young until the paste runs. They share the sweet sheep's milk flavour and the faint bitterness that thistle rennet gives, which no cow's milk cheese has. If you cannot get those, the other Portuguese thistle cheeses, Azeitao and Nisa, are close cousins and easier to find in Portuguese grocers. A very ripe Camembert is the supermarket fallback and matches the texture but not the flavour.

Why is Serra da Estrela so soft, and what happens if I use a firm cheese instead?

It is set with an extract of cardoon thistle flowers rather than animal rennet, and thistle enzymes break down milk proteins much more aggressively, so as the cheese matures the interior liquefies rather than firming up. That soft paste is not a defect, it is the product. If you substitute a firm cheese in a recipe that expects the spoonable version, you will not be able to spread it, it will not sauce the bread, and the eating experience is nothing like the original. Check whether your recipe wants the young amanteigado form or the aged velho form before you shop.

Can I use Brie instead of Serra da Estrela?

Yes, as a texture substitute, and it is the most practical option for most people. Buy the ripest Brie or Camembert in the case, let it come fully to room temperature, and cut the top rind off so you can spoon it. What you will notice is that it tastes mushroomy, buttery and a little barnyardy where Serra da Estrela tastes sweet, grassy and faintly bitter, because one is cow's milk and the other is sheep's milk set with thistle. A spoonful of honey or a good peppery olive oil over the top helps bridge that.

Can I just leave it out?

If the cheese is the dish, no. Serra da Estrela is almost always eaten as itself, on bread with wine, so there is nothing to leave out. If it appears as one component on a Portuguese cheese board or in a recipe alongside other things, you can drop it and lean on the other cheeses, or use any ripe soft cheese and a good olive oil. Where you cannot skip it is a recipe that specifically uses the runny paste as a sauce, for example spooned over roasted potatoes or steak, because that is a texture no other ingredient in your fridge provides.

Why can I not buy Serra da Estrela in the United States?

The traditional cheese is made from raw sheep's milk and eaten young, and cheeses made from unpasteurised milk and aged less than 60 days cannot legally be imported into the United States. That rules out the classic spoonable version. Some producers make a pasteurised or longer-aged export version, and Portuguese grocers in areas with large Portuguese and Azorean communities sometimes stock Azeitao or Nisa in compliant forms. This is a case where the substitute really is the practical answer rather than a compromise you should feel bad about.

Related substitutes

More cheese substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore cheese