🐟 Seafood

Fish Substitute for Salmon: Best Alternative Fish Options

Discover the best fish substitutes for salmon including trout, arctic char, and tuna. Learn which fish have similar texture, flavor, and cooking properties to salmon.

✓

Quick Answer

The best fish substitutes for salmon are trout, arctic char, tuna, and mackerel. These fish have similar texture, flavor, and cooking properties, making them excellent alternatives in most salmon recipes.

Best Substitutes

Trout

1:1

Trout is the closest substitute to salmon, with similar texture, flavor, and fat content. Rainbow trout and steelhead trout are particularly good choices as they have similar pink flesh and rich flavor.

Best for:

grillingbakingpan-fryingsmokingpoaching

Most similar to salmon in texture and flavor. Use rainbow trout or steelhead trout for best results

Arctic Char

1:1

Arctic char has a similar texture to salmon but with a milder, more delicate flavor. It's often more sustainable and affordable than salmon, making it an excellent alternative.

Best for:

grillingbakingpan-fryingpoachingsmoking

Similar to salmon but with milder flavor. Often more sustainable and affordable

Tuna

1:1

Tuna has a firmer texture than salmon but similar fat content and rich flavor. It works well in most salmon recipes, though it may need slightly different cooking times.

Best for:

grillingbakingpan-fryingsushitartare

Firmer texture than salmon but similar fat content. Use fresh tuna for best results

Mackerel

1:1

Mackerel has a stronger, more assertive flavor than salmon but similar texture and fat content. It's particularly good for grilling and smoking, and works well in marinades.

Best for:

grillingbakingsmokingcuringmarinating

Stronger flavor than salmon but similar texture and fat content. Remove skin before cooking

Steelhead Trout

1:1

Steelhead trout is very similar to salmon in appearance, flavor, and texture. It's often more affordable than salmon and works well in all the same cooking methods.

Best for:

grillingbakingpan-fryingsmokingpoaching

Very similar to salmon in appearance and flavor. Often more affordable than salmon

Sablefish (Black Cod)

1:1

Sablefish, also known as black cod, has a rich, buttery flavor similar to salmon. It's more expensive but very high quality, with a delicate texture that works well in most salmon recipes.

Best for:

grillingbakingpan-fryingsmokingpoaching

Rich, buttery flavor similar to salmon. More expensive but very high quality

Halibut

1:1

Halibut has a firmer texture than salmon but mild, sweet flavor. It works well in most salmon recipes, though it may need slightly different cooking times due to its denser texture.

Best for:

grillingbakingpan-fryingpoachingsteaming

Firmer texture than salmon but mild flavor. Use thick fillets for best results

Cooking Tips

  • 💡When substituting fish, consider the fat content - salmon is relatively fatty, so choose fish with similar fat content
  • 💡Adjust cooking times based on the thickness and density of the substitute fish
  • 💡For grilling, use a fish basket or grill mat to prevent sticking and maintain shape
  • 💡When using fish with stronger flavors, consider adjusting seasonings to complement the fish
  • 💡For smoking, choose fish with similar fat content for best results
  • 💡When poaching, use a gentle simmer and don't overcook the fish
  • 💡For pan-frying, use a non-stick pan and don't move the fish until it's ready to flip

Frequently Asked Questions

Summary

Find the best fish substitutes for salmon including trout, arctic char, and tuna. Learn which fish have similar texture, flavor, and cooking properties to salmon.