Out of anchovy paste?

Anchovy Paste Substitute for Caesar Dressing

Use this

Anchovy Fillets

Use 2-3 fillets for every 1 tsp paste

Different textureBest for classic Caesar dressing

The best anchovy paste substitute for Caesar dressing is anchovy fillets (2-3 fillets per 1 tsp paste), followed by Worcestershire sauce (1-2 tsp per 1 tsp paste), or fish sauce (1-2 tsp per 1 tsp paste). For vegetarian options, use miso paste or capers with salt.

At a glance

Every option on one screen. Tap a name for detail.

Anchovy Paste substitutes compared
#	Substitute	Instead of anchovy paste, use	Result
1	Anchovy Fillets	2-3 fillets per 1 tsp paste	Different texture
2	Worcestershire Sauce	1-2 tsp Worcestershire per 1 tsp paste	Different texture
3	Fish Sauce	1-2 tsp fish sauce per 1 tsp paste	Different texture
4	Miso Paste	1-2 tsp miso per 1 tsp paste	Different taste
5	Capers + Salt	1 tsp capers + ¼ tsp salt per 1 tsp paste	Taste and texture differ

Every anchovy paste substitute

Ranked, with the exact amount and what changes

1. Anchovy Fillets
Different texture
Use 2-3 fillets for every 1 tsp paste
Whole anchovy fillets provide the most authentic flavor for Caesar dressing.
What changes
Mash them with a fork or mince finely to distribute evenly throughout the dressing.
Best for
classic Caesar dressing, authentic flavor, traditional recipes
Mash fillets with a fork or mince finely before adding to dressing
2. Worcestershire Sauce
Different texture
Use 1-2 tsp Worcestershire for every 1 tsp paste
Worcestershire sauce contains anchovies as a key ingredient, making it an excellent substitute.
What changes
It adds complexity with additional flavors like tamarind and spices.
Best for
quick Caesar dressing, when you want complexity, convenient option
Contains anchovies but also other flavors - adjust to taste
3. Fish Sauce
Different texture
Use 1-2 tsp fish sauce for every 1 tsp paste
Fish sauce provides similar umami depth and saltiness.
What changes
It's more liquid, so you may need to adjust the oil ratio slightly in your dressing.
Best for
Asian-inspired Caesar, when you want umami depth, lighter texture
More liquid - reduce other liquids in the dressing slightly
4. Miso Paste
Different taste
Use 1-2 tsp miso for every 1 tsp paste
Miso paste provides similar umami depth without the fishy flavor.
What changes
It's perfect for vegetarian Caesar dressing and adds a unique complexity.
Best for
vegetarian Caesar dressing, when you want umami without fish, healthier option
Vegetarian option with different but pleasant flavor
5. Capers + Salt
Taste and texture differ
Use 1 tsp capers + ¼ tsp salt for every 1 tsp paste
Capers provide a briny, salty flavor similar to anchovies.
What changes
Chop them finely and add salt to achieve the right intensity for your dressing.
Best for
vegetarian Caesar dressing, when you want briny flavor, Mediterranean-inspired dressing
Vegetarian option with briny, salty flavor

This page covers one situation. For the full ranked comparison, see all 6 anchovy paste substitutes.

How it behaves in this recipe

Caesar dressing relies heavily on anchovy paste for its signature umami depth and saltiness. The paste dissolves easily in the dressing and distributes evenly, making it crucial for the authentic flavor profile. When substituting, consider both the flavor and texture impact on the final dressing.

Tips

For authentic Caesar dressing, anchovy fillets are the best substitute for paste
Mash anchovy fillets with a fork before adding to the dressing for even distribution
Worcestershire sauce adds complexity beyond just anchovy flavor - adjust other seasonings accordingly
Fish sauce is more liquid than paste - reduce oil slightly when using as substitute
Miso paste works well for vegetarian Caesar dressing but has a different flavor profile
Capers should be chopped finely to avoid chunky texture in the dressing
Taste and adjust seasonings after adding your chosen substitute
Let the dressing rest for 30 minutes to allow flavors to meld
Store Caesar dressing in the refrigerator for up to 5 days
Shake or whisk the dressing well before serving to recombine ingredients

Notes on anchovy paste

Use anchovy fillets for the most authentic flavor
Try Worcestershire sauce for added complexity
Experiment with fish sauce for Asian-inspired variations
Use miso paste for vegetarian options
Combine capers with salt for briny flavor without fish

Questions

Can I use Worcestershire sauce instead of anchovy paste in Caesar dressing?

Yes, Worcestershire sauce is an excellent substitute for anchovy paste in Caesar dressing. It contains anchovies as a key ingredient and adds complexity with additional flavors. Use 1-2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce per 1 teaspoon of anchovy paste.

What's the best vegetarian substitute for anchovy paste in Caesar dressing?

The best vegetarian substitutes are miso paste (1-2 tsp per 1 tsp paste) or capers with salt (1 tsp capers + 1/4 tsp salt per 1 tsp paste). Miso provides umami depth, while capers offer briny, salty flavor similar to anchovies.

Can I use fish sauce instead of anchovy paste in Caesar dressing?

Yes, fish sauce works well as a substitute for anchovy paste in Caesar dressing. It provides similar umami depth and saltiness. Use 1-2 teaspoons fish sauce per 1 teaspoon of anchovy paste, and consider reducing the oil slightly since fish sauce is more liquid.

How do I substitute anchovy fillets for anchovy paste in Caesar dressing?

Use 2-3 anchovy fillets per 1 teaspoon of anchovy paste. Mash the fillets with a fork or mince them finely before adding to the dressing to ensure even distribution of flavor throughout.

Will the dressing taste different with these substitutes?

Anchovy fillets will taste identical to paste. Worcestershire sauce and fish sauce will be very similar with slight differences in complexity. Miso paste and capers will have different but pleasant flavors that work well in Caesar dressing.

More anchovy paste substitutes

Browse the full guide, or the 2,551 ingredients in the index.

Anchovy Paste substitutes Browse all ingredients

At a glance

Every anchovy paste substitute

1. Anchovy Fillets

2. Worcestershire Sauce

3. Fish Sauce

4. Miso Paste

5. Capers + Salt