Out of pickled red onion?

Pickled Red Onion Substitute: Best Alternatives for Pickling

Use this

White Onions

Use the same amount as the pickled red onion you are replacing

Best for traditional pickling

For pickling, the best red onion substitutes are white onions (1:1), sweet onions like Vidalia (1:1), or shallots (1:1). White onions are traditional for pickling, sweet onions provide similar sweetness, and shallots add elegance.

At a glance

Every option on one screen. Tap a name for detail.

Pickled Red Onion substitutes compared
#	Substitute	Instead of pickled red onion, use
1	White Onions	Same amount
2	Sweet Onions (Vidalia, Walla Walla)	Same amount
3	Shallots	Same amount
4	Yellow Onions	Same amount
5	Pearl Onions	Same amount

Every pickled red onion substitute

Ranked, with the exact amount and what changes

1. White Onions
Use the same amount
White onions are the traditional choice for pickling.
What changes
They're mild and work well in pickling solutions, providing authentic flavor and texture.
Best for
traditional pickling, when you want authentic flavor, when you want mild flavor, pickling solutions, when you want traditional taste, when you want neutral color
Taste
mild, traditional pickled flavor
Texture
crisp when raw, tender when pickled
White onions are traditional for pickling and work perfectly in pickling solutions. They provide authentic flavor and mildness.
2. Sweet Onions (Vidalia, Walla Walla)
Use the same amount
Sweet onions provide similar sweetness to red onions but with less pungency.
What changes
They're perfect for pickling when you want mild, sweet flavor.
Best for
when you want sweetness, when you want mild flavor, pickling solutions, when you want similar sweetness to red onions, when you want less pungency, when you want neutral color
Taste
sweet and mild, less pungent than red onions
Texture
crisp when raw, tender when pickled
Sweet onions provide similar sweetness to red onions but with less pungency. They're perfect for pickling when you want mild, sweet flavor.
3. Shallots
Use the same amount
Shallots provide a more delicate, sweet flavor than red onions.
What changes
They're perfect for elegant pickling and add sophistication to dishes.
Best for
elegant pickling, when you want delicate flavor, gourmet pickling, when you want sophistication, fine dining pickling, when you want sweetness without pungency
Taste
delicate and sweet, more refined than red onions
Texture
tender when pickled
Shallots provide a more delicate, sweet flavor than red onions. They're perfect for elegant pickling and add sophistication to dishes.
4. Yellow Onions
Use the same amount
Yellow onions can work in pickling but are stronger than red onions.
What changes
They're good when you want more onion flavor and pungency.
Best for
when you want stronger flavor, when you want more pungency, when other onions are unavailable, when you want traditional onion flavor, when you want more bite, when you want neutral color
Taste
stronger and more pungent than red onions
Texture
firm when raw, tender when pickled
Yellow onions are stronger than red onions but can work in pickling. They provide more traditional onion flavor and pungency.
5. Pearl Onions
Use the same amount
Pearl onions provide a different texture and appearance.
What changes
They're perfect for pickling when you want small, uniform pieces.
Best for
when you want small pieces, when you want uniform size, when you want different texture, when you want different appearance, gourmet pickling, when you want elegance
Taste
mild and sweet, similar to red onions
Texture
tender when pickled
Pearl onions provide a different texture and appearance. They're perfect for pickling when you want small, uniform pieces.

This page covers one situation. For the full ranked comparison, see all 6 red onion substitutes.

How it behaves in this recipe

Red onions are popular for pickling because they're mild, sweet, and add beautiful color. When you need a substitute for red onions in pickling, choose alternatives that work well in pickling solutions and provide the flavor profile you want. The key is finding substitutes that complement your pickling solution without overwhelming other ingredients.

Tips

For pickling, choose onions that work well in pickling solutions
White onions are traditional for pickling
Sweet onions provide similar sweetness to red onions
Shallots add elegance to gourmet pickling
Yellow onions work but are stronger than red onions
Pearl onions provide different texture and appearance
Slice onions thinly for better pickling
Use fresh, firm onions for best results
Follow proper pickling procedures for safety
Store pickled onions in the refrigerator
White onions work best for most pickling applications
Sweet onions are perfect when you want similar sweetness to red onions

Notes on pickled red onion

Use different types of sweet onions for variety (Vidalia, Walla Walla, Maui)
Try using different onion varieties for custom flavor profiles
Use different types of shallots for variety
Consider using different types of white onions for variety
Mix different onion types for balanced flavor
Use different types of pearl onions for variety
Try using different types of yellow onions for variety

Questions

What's the best substitute for red onions in pickling?

White onions are the best substitute for red onions in pickling. They're traditional for pickling and provide mild, authentic flavor. Sweet onions like Vidalia also work well when you want similar sweetness.

Can I use white onions instead of red onions for pickling?

Yes, white onions are an excellent substitute for red onions in pickling. They're traditional for pickling and provide mild, authentic flavor. Use them in a 1:1 ratio.

Can I use sweet onions instead of red onions for pickling?

Yes, sweet onions like Vidalia or Walla Walla are excellent substitutes for red onions in pickling. They provide similar sweetness but with less pungency.

Can I use shallots instead of red onions for pickling?

Yes, shallots are an excellent substitute for red onions in pickling. They provide a more delicate, sweet flavor and add sophistication to dishes.

Can I use yellow onions instead of red onions for pickling?

Yes, you can use yellow onions instead of red onions for pickling, but they're stronger and more pungent. They'll provide a different flavor profile but work well in most pickling recipes.

What's the difference between red onions and white onions in pickling?

Red onions are milder and sweeter than white onions. White onions are traditional for pickling and provide authentic flavor, while red onions provide more sweetness and color.

Can I use pearl onions instead of red onions for pickling?

Yes, pearl onions can be used instead of red onions for pickling. They provide a different texture and appearance, making them perfect for gourmet pickling.

Why are red onions popular for pickling?

Red onions are popular for pickling because they're mild, sweet, and add beautiful color. They provide sweetness without overwhelming the pickling solution and work well in preserved preparations.

More red onion substitutes

Browse the full guide, or the 2,551 ingredients in the index.

Red Onion substitutes Browse all ingredients