Skip to content

Kalamata Olives substitute

Best substitute

Gaeta, Alfonso or Generic Greek Black Olives

Use the same amount as the kalamata olives you are replacing

Best for Greek salad

Close match

Any brine-cured black or purple olive is a good swap 1:1 - Gaeta, Alfonso, Amfissa and generic Greek black olives are the closest, and Nicoise olives work if you allow for their smaller size and sharper bite. What matters is that the olive was cured in brine and still tastes of it. Canned California black olives are the one common substitute that genuinely does not work on its own: they are mild, rubbery and not acidic, so if that is all you have, chop them and toss with a teaspoon of red wine vinegar and a pinch of salt per half cup before using.

Other kalamata olives substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Kalamata Olives with ratios

  1. 2Nicoise Olives

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount by volume, though you will need roughly twice as many olives

    Small brine-cured French olives with big flavour and a high pit-to-flesh ratio.

    What changes
    Best for
    salads, braises, tapenade, fish dishes, cheese boards

    Flavour is in the right family but noticeably sharper, more herbal and a little more bitter, so a Greek salad made with them tastes brighter and less mellow. Because they are so much smaller, they read as scattered specks rather than the meaty chunks Kalamatas give, and pitting them is fiddly work.

  2. 3Castelvetrano or Other Green Brine-Cured Olives

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount

    Bright green Italian and Spanish olives with a buttery, mild, faintly sweet flavour.

    What changes
    Best for
    Greek salad, pasta, roast chicken, antipasto, martinis

    Excellent olives that make a very good dish and a poor impersonation. They are far milder, sweeter and crunchier than Kalamatas, with none of the deep winey fruit, and the colour changes the look of a Greek salad or a puttanesca completely. Use slightly more and add a splash of red wine vinegar if you want the tang back.

  3. 4Oil-Cured Black Olives

    Taste and texture differ

    Use about ⅔ the amount

    Wrinkled dry-cured olives, often labelled Moroccan or oil-cured, packed in oil rather than brine.

    What changes
    Best for
    tapenade, breads, braises, roasted vegetables, pizza

    Powerfully concentrated and a completely different texture - dense, chewy and slightly bitter rather than plump and juicy, with a raisiny intensity. They are wonderful in a tapenade or baked into bread and overwhelming in a fresh salad, which is why you should use less. This is the key distinction to check on the jar: brine-cured olives taste tangy, oil-cured olives taste dark and salty.

  4. 5Canned Black Olives, Dressed

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount plus 1 teaspoon red wine vinegar and a pinch of salt per ½ cup

    Ordinary canned ripe olives, the ones almost everyone actually has, rescued with the acid and salt they lack.

    What changes
    Best for
    pizza, casseroles, pasta bakes, emergency substitution

    Be realistic about this one. Canned California olives are not brine-cured in the same sense; they are lye-treated and canned, which leaves them mild, faintly metallic and rubbery, with no fruit and no tang. Dressing them with vinegar and salt for fifteen minutes makes them usefully olive-flavoured rather than genuinely Kalamata-like. Fine on a pizza, disappointing in a Greek salad where the olive is a headline ingredient.

  5. 6Capers or Chopped Sun-Dried Tomatoes

    Taste and texture differ

    Use ½ the volume of capers, or an equal volume of sun-dried tomatoes

    Not olives at all, but two pantry items that cover the salty-briny job olives are doing in a cooked dish.

    What changes
    Best for
    pasta sauces, puttanesca, braised chicken, fish, dressings

    Capers bring the salt and sharp brine but none of the fruity richness or meaty bite, and they are much saltier, so halve the quantity and taste before adding salt elsewhere. Sun-dried tomatoes bring savoury depth and chew but read sweet rather than briny. Both work in a sauce and neither works in a salad where you would be biting into a whole olive.

What is Kalamata Olives?

Kalamata Olives is Kalamata olives are large, almond-shaped, purple-black Greek olives cured in a brine that usually includes red wine vinegar, which gives them a fruity, winey, salty flavour and meaty flesh that stays tender rather than firm.

Cooking tips

  • The single question that decides your substitute is brine-cured or oil-cured. Kalamata olives are brine-cured, so they contribute acidity along with salt and fruit. Swap in a dry oil-cured olive and you keep the salt but lose the tang, which is why a Greek salad made with wrinkled Moroccan olives tastes flat even though the olives themselves are delicious.
  • Save a spoonful of the brine from whichever jar you open. It is the fastest way to season a Greek salad dressing, a bean salad or a pan sauce, and it lets you bring a milder substitute olive closer to Kalamata's sharpness without adding straight vinegar.
  • Buy them with the pits in if you have the choice. Pitted olives sit in brine with an open channel, so they absorb water, lose flavour and turn mushier over time. Pitting a Kalamata is easy: press it firmly with the flat of a knife and the stone slips out.
  • Rinse olives briefly if a recipe already has feta, capers, anchovies or preserved lemon in it. Kalamatas are salty enough to push a dish over the edge when they are stacked with other salty ingredients, and this is the most common way a homemade Greek salad ends up inedible.
  • Add olives near the end of a long braise. Twenty minutes of simmering gives you the flavour without the flesh disintegrating; an hour turns them soft and grey and pushes bitterness into the sauce. You will also see them spelled calamata on older jars and menus, which is the same olive.

Frequently asked questions

What is the closest substitute for Kalamata olives?

Any other brine-cured purple or black olive - Gaeta, Alfonso, Amfissa or olives simply labelled Greek black olives. All swap 1:1 and share the soft flesh and fruity, winey saltiness that defines a Kalamata. Nicoise olives are the next best, allowing for their smaller size and sharper flavour.

Can I use canned black olives in a Greek salad?

You can, but it is the weakest swap on the list. Canned ripe olives are mild and rubbery with no acidity, and in a Greek salad the olive is one of only five or six ingredients, so the shortfall is obvious. Chop them, toss with red wine vinegar and salt, and let them sit fifteen minutes before adding, which at least gives them some tang.

Can I leave the olives out?

In a pasta sauce, a braise or on a pizza, yes - add a teaspoon of capers or an extra pinch of salt plus a splash of vinegar to replace the briny hit and the dish will hold up. In a Greek salad, a tapenade or a puttanesca, no; the olives are a defining component rather than a seasoning, and leaving them out means making a different dish.

Are green olives a good substitute for Kalamata olives?

They are a good ingredient and a mediocre substitute. Green olives such as Castelvetrano or Manzanilla are firmer, milder and often sweeter, so the dish loses the deep purple colour and the winey fruit that makes a Kalamata distinctive. Use them when you want a nice olive rather than when you want to hide the switch.

Why do Kalamata olives taste different from other black olives?

Because of how they are cured. Kalamatas are brine-cured, often with red wine vinegar in the brine, and they are picked fully ripe, which gives them their purple-black colour, tender flesh and tangy fruit. Most canned black olives are picked green and treated with lye, which is why they taste so much blander despite looking similar.

Related substitutes

More vegetables & aromatics substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore vegetables & aromatics