🌿 Spices & Herbs

Italian Seasoning Substitute for Pasta: Best Alternatives

Discover the best Italian seasoning substitutes for pasta including oregano, basil, and homemade blends. Find the perfect alternative for every pasta recipe.

✓

Quick Answer

The best Italian seasoning substitutes for pasta are oregano (for authentic flavor), basil + oregano combination (for balanced taste), or a homemade mix of oregano, basil, thyme, and rosemary. For quick substitutes, use pizza seasoning or Mediterranean seasoning. The choice depends on your recipe and available ingredients.

Best Substitutes

Oregano

1:1

Oregano is the primary herb in Italian seasoning and works perfectly for pasta. It has the authentic Italian flavor that complements pasta dishes beautifully.

Best for:

pastapizzasaucesmarinades

Primary herb in Italian seasoning, authentic flavor

Basil + Oregano

1:1 (equal parts)

Mix equal parts dried basil and oregano to create the perfect pasta seasoning. This combination captures the essential Italian flavors and works well in most pasta dishes.

Best for:

pastapizzasaucesmarinades

Two main herbs, balanced flavor

Homemade Italian Seasoning Mix

2 tsp oregano, 1 tsp basil, 1 tsp thyme, 1/2 tsp rosemary, 1/2 tsp marjoram

Make your own Italian seasoning by mixing dried oregano, basil, thyme, rosemary, and marjoram. This gives you the most authentic flavor for pasta dishes.

Best for:

all pasta recipessaucesmarinades

Complete herb blend, most accurate

Pizza Seasoning

1:1

Pizza seasoning is similar to Italian seasoning and works well for pasta. It typically contains oregano, basil, and other Italian herbs that complement pasta dishes.

Best for:

pastapizzaItalian dishes

Similar herb blend, pizza-focused

Mediterranean Seasoning

1:1

Mediterranean seasoning is similar to Italian seasoning and works well for pasta. It contains many of the same herbs and spices with a comparable flavor profile.

Best for:

pastacookingmarinades

Similar herb blend, Mediterranean origin

Thyme + Rosemary

1:1 (equal parts)

Mix equal parts dried thyme and rosemary for a woody herb substitute. This works well in heartier pasta dishes where you want bold flavor.

Best for:

pastasaucesmarinades

Woody herbs, hearty flavor

Parsley + Oregano

1:1 (equal parts)

Mix equal parts dried parsley and oregano for a fresh-tasting substitute. This works well in lighter pasta dishes where you want brightness.

Best for:

pastasaucesgarnishes

Fresh herbs, lighter flavor

Garlic + Oregano

1:1 (equal parts)

Mix equal parts garlic powder and oregano for a flavorful substitute. This adds both herb and garlic flavors that work well with pasta.

Best for:

pastasaucesmarinades

Garlic and herb combination

Basil + Thyme

1:1 (equal parts)

Mix equal parts dried basil and thyme for a balanced herb substitute. This works well in pasta dishes where you want both sweetness and earthiness.

Best for:

pastasaucesmarinades

Herb combination, balanced flavor

Herbes de Provence

1:1

Herbes de Provence is a French herb blend that's similar to Italian seasoning. It works well for pasta and contains many of the same herbs.

Best for:

pastacookingmarinades

French herb blend, similar flavor

Cooking Tips

  • 💡For tomato-based pasta: Use oregano or basil + oregano combination
  • 💡In cream-based pasta: Use thyme + rosemary or Mediterranean seasoning
  • 💡For pesto pasta: Use basil + oregano or homemade mix
  • 💡In meat pasta: Use oregano or pizza seasoning for bold flavor
  • 💡For vegetable pasta: Use parsley + oregano or fines herbes
  • 💡In seafood pasta: Use thyme + rosemary or Mediterranean seasoning
  • 💡For spicy pasta: Use oregano + red pepper flakes
  • 💡In baked pasta: Use homemade mix or pizza seasoning
  • 💡For cold pasta: Use parsley + oregano or fines herbes
  • 💡In stuffed pasta: Use basil + oregano or homemade mix

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta?

The best substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta is oregano (for authentic flavor), basil + oregano combination (for balanced taste), or a homemade mix of oregano, basil, thyme, and rosemary. For quick substitutes, use pizza seasoning or Mediterranean seasoning.

Can I use oregano instead of Italian seasoning in pasta?

Yes, oregano is the primary herb in Italian seasoning and works perfectly for pasta. It has the authentic Italian flavor that complements pasta dishes beautifully. Use a 1:1 ratio.

What's the best substitute for Italian seasoning in tomato pasta?

For tomato-based pasta, use oregano or a combination of basil + oregano. These herbs complement the acidity of tomatoes and provide the classic Italian flavor.

Can I use basil + oregano as a substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta?

Yes, basil + oregano is an excellent substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta. Mix equal parts dried basil and oregano to create the perfect pasta seasoning that captures the essential Italian flavors.

What's the best substitute for Italian seasoning in cream pasta?

For cream-based pasta, use thyme + rosemary or Mediterranean seasoning. These herbs complement the richness of cream sauces and provide depth of flavor.

Can I use pizza seasoning as a substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta?

Yes, pizza seasoning is a good substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta. It typically contains oregano, basil, and other Italian herbs that work well with pasta dishes. Use a 1:1 ratio.

What's the best substitute for Italian seasoning in meat pasta?

For meat pasta, use oregano or pizza seasoning for bold flavor. These herbs complement the richness of meat and provide the classic Italian taste.

Can I use Mediterranean seasoning as a substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta?

Yes, Mediterranean seasoning is a good substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta. It contains many of the same herbs and spices with a comparable flavor profile. Use a 1:1 ratio.

What's the best substitute for Italian seasoning in vegetable pasta?

For vegetable pasta, use parsley + oregano or fines herbes. These herbs complement the freshness of vegetables and provide a lighter flavor profile.

Can I use thyme + rosemary as a substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta?

Yes, thyme + rosemary is a good substitute for Italian seasoning in pasta. Mix equal parts dried thyme and rosemary for a woody herb blend that works well in heartier pasta dishes.

Summary

Best Italian seasoning substitutes for pasta including oregano, basil, and homemade blends. Find the perfect alternative for every pasta recipe.