Out of Holland pepper, one case
Substitute for Holland pepper
6 options, ranked, with the exact amount
Use Bell peppers
Same amount as the Holland pepper
The best substitutes for Holland pepper are bell peppers, poblano peppers, and Anaheim peppers. Use 1:1 ratio for most substitutes, adjusting cooking time based on the pepper's thickness and heat level.
- Best for —
- stuffed peppers
One casethe full Holland pepper card
Every option, one card
Ranked| # | Substitute | Instead of Holland pepper |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bell peppersstuffed peppers | Same amount |
| 2 | Poblano peppersstuffed peppers | Same amount |
| 3 | Anaheim peppersstuffed peppers | Same amount |
| 4 | Cubanelle peppersstir-fries | Same amount |
| 5 | Banana pepperspickling | Same amount |
| 6 | Sweet peppers (mixed)mixed dishes | Same amount |
Bell peppers
similar sweetness
Sweet, mild peppers with thick flesh similar to Holland peppers. Available in red, green, yellow, and orange varieties with similar texture and cooking properties.
- Best for
- stuffed peppers, stir-fries, roasting, salads, fajitas, soups, grilling
- Texture
- similar thick flesh
Most similar to Holland peppers in texture and sweetness. Red bell peppers are slightly sweeter than green ones.
Poblano peppers
similar with mild heat
Mild to medium heat peppers with thick flesh, good for stuffing and roasting. Slightly more heat than Holland peppers but similar texture.
- Best for
- stuffed peppers, roasting, chiles rellenos, stir-fries, soups, sauces, grilling
- Texture
- similar thick flesh
Slightly more heat than Holland peppers but similar thick flesh. Great for Mexican and Southwestern dishes.
Anaheim peppers
similar mild flavor
Mild peppers with good flesh thickness, excellent for stuffing and roasting. Very similar heat level to Holland peppers.
- Best for
- stuffed peppers, roasting, stir-fries, soups, sauces, grilling, fajitas
- Texture
- similar thick flesh
Very similar to Holland peppers in heat level and texture. Long, narrow shape works well for stuffing.
Cubanelle peppers
similar sweetness
Sweet, mild peppers with thin skin and good flesh, good for quick cooking methods like stir-frying and sautéing.
- Best for
- stir-fries, sautés, salads, quick cooking, fajitas, soups
- Texture
- thinner skin, similar flesh
Thinner skin than Holland peppers but similar sweetness. Cooks faster due to thinner skin.
Banana peppers
similar sweetness
Mild, sweet peppers with good texture, good for pickling and quick cooking applications. Similar sweetness to Holland peppers.
- Best for
- pickling, stir-fries, salads, sandwiches, quick cooking, soups
- Texture
- similar but different shape
Similar sweetness to Holland peppers but different shape. Great for pickling and quick cooking methods.
Sweet peppers (mixed)
similar sweetness
Any combination of sweet peppers including bell peppers, cubanelle, and other mild varieties for variety in color and flavor.
- Best for
- mixed dishes, stir-fries, roasting, soups, salads, fajitas
- Texture
- varies by type
Use any combination of sweet peppers for variety in color and flavor. All work well as Holland pepper substitutes.
Tips for substituting Holland pepper
6 tips- Holland peppers are mild and sweet, so choose substitutes with similar heat levels
- For stuffed peppers, bell peppers and poblano peppers work best due to their thick flesh and similar shape
- Holland peppers are great for roasting - Anaheim peppers are the closest substitute for this method
- For stir-fries, cubanelle peppers work well due to their thinner skin and quick cooking time
- Holland peppers pair well with vegetables, meats, and herbs in most recipes
- Store Holland pepper substitutes in the refrigerator for up to a week for best quality
Questions
7 questionsWhat's the best substitute for Holland pepper in stuffed peppers?
Bell peppers and poblano peppers work best for stuffed peppers due to their thick flesh and similar shape. Poblano peppers have slightly more heat but similar texture.
Can I use bell peppers instead of Holland pepper?
Yes, bell peppers are an excellent substitute for Holland pepper. They have similar sweetness and thick flesh, making them good for most recipes.
What's the difference between Holland pepper and other sweet peppers?
Holland peppers are a specific variety of sweet pepper known for their mild flavor and thick flesh. They're similar to bell peppers but may have slightly different growing characteristics.
Which substitute works best for roasting Holland peppers?
Anaheim peppers work best for roasting as they have similar heat level and thick flesh. Bell peppers also work well for roasting applications.
Are there any substitutes that are spicier than Holland peppers?
Poblano peppers have slightly more heat than Holland peppers, while bell peppers and Anaheim peppers have similar mild heat levels. Choose based on your heat preference.
Can I use Holland pepper substitutes in pickling?
Yes, banana peppers and cubanelle peppers work well for pickling. Bell peppers can also be pickled, though they may have a different texture than traditional pickled peppers.
How do I choose the right substitute for my recipe?
Consider your cooking method: bell peppers for stuffing, Anaheim peppers for roasting, cubanelle peppers for stir-frying, and poblano peppers for Mexican dishes. Match the heat level to your preference.