Out of Red Holland pepper, one case
Red Holland pepper substitute
6 options, ranked, with the exact amount
Use Red bell peppers
Same amount as the red Holland pepper
The best red Holland pepper substitutes are red bell peppers, red poblano peppers, and red Anaheim peppers. Use 1:1 ratio for most substitutes, with red bell peppers being the closest match in sweetness and color.
- Best for —
- stuffed peppers
One casethe full Holland pepper card
Every option, one card
Ranked| # | Substitute | Instead of red Holland pepper |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Red bell peppersstuffed peppers | Same amount |
| 2 | Red poblano peppersstuffed peppers | Same amount |
| 3 | Red Anaheim peppersstuffed peppers | Same amount |
| 4 | Red cubanelle peppersstir-fries | Same amount |
| 5 | Red banana pepperspickling | Same amount |
| 6 | Red sweet peppers (mixed)mixed dishes | Same amount |
Red bell peppers
similar sweetness
Sweet, mild red peppers with thick flesh, good substitute for red Holland peppers. Similar sweetness and color with excellent texture.
- Best for
- stuffed peppers, stir-fries, roasting, salads, fajitas, soups, grilling
- Texture
- similar thick flesh
Most similar to red Holland peppers in sweetness, color, and texture. Red bell peppers are slightly sweeter than green ones.
Red poblano peppers
similar with mild heat
Mild to medium heat red peppers with thick flesh, good for stuffing and roasting. Similar heat level and texture to red Holland peppers.
- Best for
- stuffed peppers, roasting, chiles rellenos, stir-fries, soups, sauces, grilling
- Texture
- similar thick flesh
Similar heat level and texture to red Holland peppers. Great for Mexican and Southwestern dishes with red color.
Red Anaheim peppers
similar mild flavor
Mild red peppers with good flesh thickness, excellent for stuffing and roasting. Very similar heat level to red Holland peppers.
- Best for
- stuffed peppers, roasting, stir-fries, soups, sauces, grilling, fajitas
- Texture
- similar thick flesh
Very similar to red Holland peppers in heat level and texture. Long, narrow shape works well for stuffing.
Red cubanelle peppers
similar sweetness
Sweet, mild red peppers with thin skin and good flesh, good for quick cooking methods. Similar sweetness to red Holland peppers.
- Best for
- stir-fries, sautés, salads, quick cooking, fajitas, soups
- Texture
- thinner skin, similar flesh
Thinner skin than red Holland peppers but similar sweetness and color. Cooks faster due to thinner skin.
Red banana peppers
similar sweetness
Mild, sweet red peppers with good texture, good for pickling and quick cooking applications. Similar sweetness to red Holland peppers.
- Best for
- pickling, stir-fries, salads, sandwiches, quick cooking, soups
- Texture
- similar but different shape
Similar sweetness and mild heat to red Holland peppers. Great for pickling and quick cooking methods.
Red sweet peppers (mixed)
similar sweetness
Any combination of red sweet peppers including red bell peppers, red cubanelle, and other mild red varieties for variety in flavor.
- Best for
- mixed dishes, stir-fries, roasting, soups, salads, fajitas
- Texture
- varies by type
Use any combination of red sweet peppers for variety in flavor while maintaining the red color. All work well as red Holland pepper substitutes.
Tips for substituting red Holland pepper
6 tips- Red Holland peppers are mild and sweet, so choose red substitutes with similar heat levels
- For stuffed peppers, red bell peppers and red poblano peppers work best due to their thick flesh and similar shape
- Red Holland peppers are great for roasting - red Anaheim peppers are the closest substitute for this method
- For stir-fries, red cubanelle peppers work well due to their thinner skin and quick cooking time
- Red Holland peppers pair well with vegetables, meats, and herbs in most recipes
- Red peppers are sweeter than green peppers, so they work well in both sweet and savory dishes
Questions
7 questionsWhat's the best substitute for red Holland pepper in stuffed peppers?
Red bell peppers work best for stuffed peppers as they have similar sweetness, color, and thick flesh. Red poblano peppers also work well if you want slightly more heat.
Can I use red bell peppers instead of red Holland pepper?
Yes, red bell peppers are an excellent substitute for red Holland pepper. They have similar sweetness, color, and thick flesh, making them good for most recipes.
What's the difference between red Holland pepper and other red peppers?
Red Holland peppers are a specific variety of sweet red pepper known for their mild flavor and thick flesh. They're similar to red bell peppers but may have slightly different growing characteristics.
Which red pepper substitute works best for roasting?
Red Anaheim peppers work best for roasting as they have similar heat level and thick flesh. Red bell peppers also work well for roasting applications.
Are red Holland peppers sweeter than green ones?
Yes, red Holland peppers are sweeter than green ones, just like red bell peppers are sweeter than green bell peppers. This makes them good for both sweet and savory dishes.
Can I use red Holland pepper substitutes in Mexican dishes?
Yes, red poblano peppers are good for Mexican dishes like chiles rellenos and stuffed peppers. Red Anaheim peppers also work well in Southwestern and Mexican cuisine.
Do red pepper substitutes work well for pickling?
Yes, red banana peppers and red cubanelle peppers work well for pickling. Red bell peppers can also be pickled, though they may have a different texture than traditional pickled peppers.