Skip to content

Hilbet substitute

Best substitute

Hummus with ground fenugreek

1 cup hummus + ½ to 1 tsp ground fenugreek + 1 crushed garlic clove + squeeze of lemon

Best for no cooking at all

Different texture

The fastest genuinely good answer, because hummus already does most of hilbet's job: a creamy, savoury, oil-enriched legume spread for bread.

Other hilbet substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Hilbet with ratios

  1. 2Homemade hilbet from fenugreek seeds and red lentils

    Close match

    ¼ cup fenugreek seeds soaked overnight and rinsed, ½ cup red lentils cooked soft, 2 garlic cloves, 1 tsp grated ginger, 1 tsp berbere, 2 tbsp oil, salt and lemon to taste

    This is not really a substitute, it is the dish itself, and it is worth listing because the ingredients are ordinary and the method is the only part people get wrong.

    What changes
    Best for
    the real thing, fasting-season cooking, making a batch to keep for a few days

    The whole technique is in the soaking and rinsing. Soak the seeds overnight, then drain and rinse two or three times, squeezing the slippery gel out between rinses; that is what removes the harsh bitterness and leaves the pleasant bittersweet aroma behind. Blend everything with just enough water to move, then beat in the oil at the end.

  2. 3Mashed fava beans (ful medames) with fenugreek

    Different taste

    Use the same amount as a spread, plus ½ tsp ground fenugreek per cup

    Canned or cooked fava beans mashed with garlic and oil give a legume paste with real body, and fava is closer to the beans some households actually use in hilbet.

    What changes
    Best for
    widely available in tins, a heartier, more filling spread, Middle Eastern and African groceries

    It comes out earthier and beanier with visible texture, and darker in colour than hilbet's pale cream, so the plate looks different. Tinned ful is usually already seasoned with cumin, which pushes the flavour toward Egyptian breakfast rather than Eritrean fasting food. Rinse a plain tin if you can find one, and mash rather than blend so it keeps some grain.

  3. 4Red lentil puree with fenugreek and garlic

    Taste and texture differ

    1 cup cooked red lentils blended with ½ tsp ground fenugreek, 2 garlic cloves, 2 tbsp oil, salt and lemon

    Red lentils cook to a soft puree in fifteen minutes and give a pale, mild base that takes fenugreek well.

    What changes
    Best for
    cooking from pantry staples, controlling the seasoning exactly, a smooth spread without tahini flavour

    The colour and mildness are close and it tastes noticeably sweeter and cleaner than hilbet, with less of the bitter counterpoint. Because there is no fenugreek seed in it there is no mucilage, so it sits on the injera in a soft mound instead of clinging to it. Keep it thicker than you think you want; lentil puree loosens as it cools less than fenugreek paste tightens.

  4. 5Fenugreek-spiked yogurt or labneh

    Taste and texture differ

    ½ cup thick yogurt + ¼ tsp ground fenugreek + 1 small crushed garlic clove

    A quick creamy condiment that carries the fenugreek aroma, for meals where the fasting rules do not apply.

    What changes
    Best for
    a fast table condiment, non-fasting meals, cutting through berbere-heavy stews

    This is tangy and cooling where hilbet is savoury and faintly bitter, and it is dairy, which defeats the purpose entirely on a fasting plate where hilbet is one of the only rich things allowed. As a general spread beside spicy stews it is genuinely good. As a stand-in for hilbet specifically, it changes both the flavour and the point.

  5. 6Plain hummus with no fenugreek (least-bad option)

    Taste and texture differ

    Use the same amount

    Listed honestly: it gives you something creamy and savoury to spread, and it does not taste like hilbet at all.

    What changes
    Best for
    when the shop has no fenugreek in any form, guests who dislike bitter flavours

    Fenugreek is the entire identity of hilbet, so hummus without it is simply hummus on injera. It fills the same slot on the plate and provides the same richness, which is not nothing, but the distinctive bittersweet aroma that people recognise hilbet by is completely absent. If you can get fenugreek in any form, even a teaspoon of curry powder that contains it, use it.

What is Hilbet?

Hilbet is Hilbet is the Eritrean and Tigrayan fenugreek paste, a pale savoury spread made from soaked and rinsed fenugreek seeds blended with lentils or fava beans, garlic, ginger and oil, and eaten with injera.

Cooking tips

  • Soak fenugreek seeds overnight, then drain and rinse them two or three times, squeezing the gel out as you go. Skipping this is the single most common reason homemade hilbet comes out inedibly bitter, and no amount of garlic or lemon afterwards will rescue it.
  • Fenugreek keeps thickening as it stands, because of the mucilage in the seed. Make hilbet looser than you want to serve it and expect it to firm up within an hour; if it has set too stiff, beat in a spoonful of water and a little oil rather than reheating it.
  • If you are using ground fenugreek instead of seeds, toast it barely or not at all. Over-toasted fenugreek turns acrid and tastes of burnt maple syrup, and unlike bitterness from unrinsed seed it cannot be diluted away.
  • Serve hilbet at room temperature. It is a spread, not a hot stew, and chilling it dulls the aroma while heating it makes the texture slack and gluey.
  • Beat a tablespoon of oil in at the very end. On a fasting plate hilbet is one of the few sources of fat, and that final oil both smooths the texture and carries fenugreek's aroma, which is fat-soluble and tastes muted without it.

Frequently asked questions

Can I just leave hilbet out?

On a fasting or vegan beyaynetu, you can, but you will notice. Hilbet is one of the few genuinely rich things on a plate that is otherwise stews and greens, so the meal comes out leaner and more monotonous without it. If you skip it, add another oil-rich dish such as shiro or a well-oiled lentil stew in its place rather than just serving less food.

Is hilbet the same as fenugreek?

No, and this is the most common confusion. Fenugreek is a spice, a hard bitter seed sold in a jar. Hilbet is a prepared paste in which soaked and rinsed fenugreek seeds are blended with legumes, garlic, ginger, oil and often a little berbere. Buying a jar of fenugreek and spooning it onto injera gets you nowhere; the seeds have to be soaked, rinsed and blended into something.

Why is my hilbet so bitter?

Almost certainly because the fenugreek seeds were not soaked long enough or not rinsed enough. Fenugreek carries a lot of bitterness that leaches out in water, and the traditional method is a long soak followed by several rinses with the gel squeezed out each time. Using ground fenugreek instead of seeds causes the same problem for a different reason: you cannot rinse a powder, so you have to use far less of it.

Is hilbet vegan?

Traditionally yes. Hilbet is a fasting food, made specifically for the Orthodox fasting periods when animal products are avoided, so the standard version is fenugreek, legumes, aromatics, salt and vegetable oil. If you are substituting for it on a fasting plate, avoid the yogurt option and stay with the hummus, ful or lentil versions.

Can I use ground fenugreek instead of whole seeds?

Yes, but use dramatically less. Ground fenugreek cannot be soaked and rinsed, so all of its bitterness stays in the dish. Where a recipe uses a quarter cup of whole soaked seeds, start with about a teaspoon of the powder, taste, and add more cautiously. The aroma will be right; the balance is easy to overshoot.

Related substitutes

More sauces & condiments substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore sauces & condiments