🍯 Sauces & Condiments

Gravy Substitute for Mashed Potatoes: Complete Guide

Find the best gravy substitutes for mashed potatoes. Learn about butter, cream, and other alternatives with proper ratios and tips.

✓

Quick Answer

The best gravy substitutes for mashed potatoes are butter + cream (2 tbsp butter + 1/4 cup cream), sour cream (1/4 cup), or olive oil + herbs (2 tbsp oil + 1 tsp herbs). Butter + cream provides the most similar richness.

Best Substitutes

Butter + Cream

2 tbsp butter + 1/4 cup cream

Butter with cream is the best gravy substitute for mashed potatoes. It provides similar richness and creaminess without the need for gravy.

Best for:

mashed potatoeswhen you want richnesscreamy texturemost applications

Mix butter and cream into mashed potatoes for richness and creaminess. This provides similar satisfaction to gravy without the need for a separate sauce.

Sour Cream

1/4 cup

Sour cream is an excellent gravy substitute for mashed potatoes. It provides tanginess and creaminess that complements the potatoes well.

Best for:

mashed potatoeswhen you want tanginesscreamy textureconvenience

Mix sour cream into mashed potatoes for tanginess and creaminess. This provides a different but satisfying flavor profile.

Olive Oil + Herbs

2 tbsp oil + 1 tsp herbs

Olive oil with herbs is a healthy gravy substitute for mashed potatoes. It provides richness and flavor without the heaviness of gravy.

Best for:

mashed potatoeswhen you want healthy optionherb flavorlight texture

Drizzle olive oil over mashed potatoes and sprinkle with herbs. This provides richness and flavor without the need for gravy.

Cheese + Milk

1/2 cup cheese + 1/4 cup milk

Cheese with milk is a rich gravy substitute for mashed potatoes. It provides creaminess and flavor that complements the potatoes well.

Best for:

mashed potatoeswhen you want cheese flavorcreamy texturerichness

Mix cheese and milk into mashed potatoes for creaminess and flavor. This provides a satisfying alternative to gravy.

Yogurt + Herbs

1/4 cup yogurt + 1 tsp herbs

Yogurt with herbs is a healthy gravy substitute for mashed potatoes. It provides tanginess and creaminess with added health benefits.

Best for:

mashed potatoeswhen you want healthy optiontanginesscreamy texture

Mix yogurt and herbs into mashed potatoes for tanginess and creaminess. This provides a healthy alternative to gravy.

Cream Cheese + Milk

2 tbsp cream cheese + 1/4 cup milk

Cream cheese with milk is a rich gravy substitute for mashed potatoes. It provides creaminess and tanginess that complements the potatoes well.

Best for:

mashed potatoeswhen you want creaminesstanginessrichness

Mix cream cheese and milk into mashed potatoes for creaminess and tanginess. This provides a satisfying alternative to gravy.

Cooking Tips

  • 💡Gravy substitutes for mashed potatoes should provide richness and flavor
  • 💡Butter + cream provides the most similar satisfaction to gravy
  • 💡Sour cream adds tanginess that complements potatoes well
  • 💡Olive oil + herbs provides a healthy alternative
  • 💡Cheese + milk adds creaminess and flavor
  • 💡Yogurt + herbs provides tanginess with health benefits
  • 💡Cream cheese + milk adds creaminess and tanginess

Frequently Asked Questions

Summary

Find the best gravy substitutes for mashed potatoes. Learn about butter, cream, and other alternatives with proper ratios and tips.