Skip to content

Out of Gravy master, one case

Gravy master substitutes

6 options, ranked, with the exact amount

Use thisBest of 6 options

Use Kitchen bouquet

Same amount as the gravy master

The best substitutes for Gravy Master are Kitchen Bouquet (1:1), Worcestershire sauce (1:1), or soy sauce + molasses (1:1 + 1 tsp molasses). Kitchen Bouquet provides the most similar color and flavor.

Verdict —
Works
Best for —
gravies

One casethe full gravy card

Every option, one card

Ranked
Gravy master substitutes compared
SubstituteInstead of gravy master
Kitchen bouquetgraviesSame amountWorks
Worcestershire saucegraviesSame amountWorks
Soy sauce + molassesgraviesSame amountPlus 1 tsp molassesWorks
Browning saucegraviesSame amountWorks
Dark soy saucegraviesSame amountWorks
Caramelized onions + brothgravies¼ cup onions + 1 cup brothTweak it
What changes6 options

Kitchen bouquet

similar taste and texture

Kitchen Bouquet is the closest substitute for Gravy Master. It provides similar color, flavor, and browning properties for gravies and sauces.

Best for
gravies, sauces, when you want similar color, browning

Kitchen Bouquet provides similar color and flavor to Gravy Master. Use equal amounts and add gradually to achieve desired color and flavor.

Worcestershire sauce

similar taste and texture

Worcestershire sauce provides similar flavor and color to Gravy Master. It adds depth and complexity to gravies and sauces.

Best for
gravies, sauces, when you want similar flavor, enhanced taste

Worcestershire sauce provides similar flavor to Gravy Master. Use equal amounts and add gradually to achieve desired flavor.

Soy sauce + molasses

enhanced taste, similar texture

Soy sauce with molasses creates a rich, dark substitute for Gravy Master. It provides similar color and depth of flavor.

Best for
gravies, sauces, when you want rich color, enhanced flavor

Mix soy sauce with molasses to create a rich, dark substitute. Add gradually to achieve desired color and flavor.

Browning sauce

similar taste and texture

Browning sauce provides similar color and flavor to Gravy Master. It's specifically designed for darkening gravies and sauces.

Best for
gravies, sauces, when you want similar color, browning

Browning sauce provides similar color and flavor to Gravy Master. Use equal amounts and add gradually to achieve desired color.

Dark soy sauce

similar taste and texture

Dark soy sauce provides rich color and flavor similar to Gravy Master. It's good for darkening gravies and sauces.

Best for
gravies, sauces, when you want rich color, Asian-inspired dishes

Dark soy sauce provides rich color and flavor. Use equal amounts and add gradually to achieve desired color and flavor.

Caramelized onions + broth

enhanced taste, different texture

Caramelized onions provide natural color and flavor to gravies. This creates a rich, dark substitute for Gravy Master.

Best for
gravies, sauces, when you want natural color, enhanced flavor

Caramelize onions until dark brown, then add to broth. Simmer until desired color and flavor is achieved.

How gravy master compares

The differenceGravy master

Gravy Master is used to darken and flavor gravies and sauces. The key is achieving the right color and depth of flavor. When substituting, consider whether you need the color, flavor, or both properties of Gravy Master.

Tips for substituting gravy master

7 tips
  1. Gravy Master is used to darken and flavor gravies and sauces
  2. Add substitutes gradually to achieve desired color and flavor
  3. Kitchen Bouquet provides the most similar color to Gravy Master
  4. Worcestershire sauce adds depth and complexity to gravies
  5. Soy sauce with molasses creates a rich, dark substitute
  6. Taste and adjust seasoning as needed
  7. Store substitutes in a cool, dry place

Notes on gravy master

Also on file3 notes
  1. For a completely different approach, try using other browning agents like liquid smoke or dark broths
  2. In some applications, you could use a combination of different browning agents for layered flavor
  3. For natural options, consider using caramelized vegetables or dark roasted ingredients

Questions

7 questions

What's the best substitute for Gravy Master?

Kitchen Bouquet (1:1) is the best substitute for Gravy Master. Worcestershire sauce (1:1) provides similar flavor, while soy sauce + molasses (1:1 + 1 tsp molasses) creates a rich, dark substitute.

Can I use Kitchen Bouquet instead of Gravy Master?

Yes, Kitchen Bouquet is an excellent substitute for Gravy Master. Use equal amounts (1:1 ratio) and add gradually to achieve desired color and flavor.

What is Gravy Master used for?

Gravy Master is used to darken and flavor gravies and sauces. It provides rich color and depth of flavor to enhance the appearance and taste of dishes.

Can I use Worcestershire sauce instead of Gravy Master?

Yes, Worcestershire sauce is a good substitute for Gravy Master. Use equal amounts (1:1 ratio) and add gradually to achieve desired flavor.

How do I make a Gravy Master substitute?

Mix soy sauce with molasses (1:1 + 1 tsp molasses) to create a rich, dark substitute. Add gradually to gravies and sauces to achieve desired color and flavor.

What's the difference between Gravy Master and Kitchen Bouquet?

Gravy Master and Kitchen Bouquet are very similar products used to darken and flavor gravies. Kitchen Bouquet is more widely available and provides similar results.

Can I make gravy without Gravy Master?

Yes, you can make gravy without Gravy Master by using natural browning techniques like caramelizing onions or using dark broths. The substitutes mentioned above also work well.

All 6 gravy substitutes All ingredients