Skip to content

Out of Capsicum paste, one case

Capsicum paste substitutes: concentrated pepper alternatives

5 options, ranked, with the exact amount

Use thisBest of 5 options

Use Bell pepper paste

Same amount as the capsicum paste

For capsicum paste, the best substitutes are Bell Pepper Paste, Roasted Red Pepper Paste, and Piquillo Pepper Paste. Use 1:1 ratio and follow these concentrated pepper techniques for optimal results.

Verdict —
Works
Best for —
cooking

One casethe full capsicum card

Every option, one card

Ranked
Capsicum paste substitutes compared
SubstituteInstead of capsicum paste
Bell pepper pastecookingSame amountWorks
Roasted red pepper pastecookingSame amountTweak it
Piquillo pepper pastecookingSame amount
Tomato paste + bell peppercookingSame amountTweak it
Sun-dried tomato pastecookingSame amountTweak it
What changes5 options

Bell pepper paste

similar taste and texture

Bell pepper paste provides similar sweetness and texture to capsicum paste. Good for when you want the same functionality with mild, sweet flavor.

Best for
cooking, when you want identical results, sweetness, general use, most capsicum paste recipes

Use in equal amounts by volume. Bell pepper paste has similar sweetness and texture to capsicum paste. Ideal for all applications where capsicum paste is called for.

Roasted red pepper paste

different taste, similar texture

Roasted red pepper paste provides similar sweetness to capsicum paste with added smoky flavor. Good for when you want the capsicum paste character with depth and complexity.

Best for
cooking, when you want smoky flavor, depth, complexity, most capsicum paste recipes

Use in equal amounts by volume. Roasted red pepper paste has a slightly different flavor but similar sweetness. Ideal for recipes where you want smoky taste.

Piquillo pepper paste

slightly different · similar texture

Piquillo pepper paste provides similar sweetness to capsicum paste with mild heat. Good for when you want the capsicum paste character with a slight spiciness.

Best for
cooking, when you want mild heat, sweetness, Spanish dishes, most capsicum paste recipes

Use in equal amounts by volume. Piquillo pepper paste has a slightly different flavor but similar sweetness. Ideal for recipes where you want mild heat.

Tomato paste + bell pepper

different taste, similar texture

Tomato paste with bell pepper provides similar texture to capsicum paste with added acidity. Good for when you want the capsicum paste character with tomato flavor.

Best for
cooking, when you want tomato flavor, acidity, texture, most capsicum paste recipes

Use in equal amounts by volume. Tomato paste with bell pepper has a slightly different flavor but similar texture. Ideal for recipes where you want tomato taste.

Sun-dried tomato paste

different taste, similar texture

Sun-dried tomato paste provides similar texture to capsicum paste with concentrated flavor. Good for when you want the capsicum paste character with intense tomato taste.

Best for
cooking, when you want intense flavor, concentration, texture, most capsicum paste recipes

Use in equal amounts by volume. Sun-dried tomato paste has a different flavor but similar texture. Ideal for recipes where you want intense taste.

How it behaves in this recipe

In this recipeCapsicum paste

When using capsicum paste substitutes, the goal is to replicate the sweetness, texture, and functionality that capsicum paste provides. The recommended substitutes work because they offer similar sweetness levels with complementary flavor profiles while maintaining the intended functionality in cooking and recipes.

Tips for substituting capsicum paste

8 tips
  1. For capsicum paste in cooking, use bell pepper paste for the most similar results
  2. When making capsicum paste sauces, use roasted red pepper paste for added depth
  3. For capsicum paste in marinades, use piquillo pepper paste for mild spiciness
  4. In capsicum paste soups, use tomato paste with bell pepper for acidity
  5. For capsicum paste in casseroles, use sun-dried tomato paste for intensity
  6. When making capsicum paste dips, use bell pepper paste for sweetness
  7. For capsicum paste in pasta, use roasted red pepper paste for complexity
  8. In capsicum paste spreads, use piquillo pepper paste for flavor

Notes on capsicum paste

Also on file5 notes
  1. For capsicum paste in cooking: Use bell pepper paste for similar results
  2. For capsicum paste in sauces: Use roasted red pepper paste for depth
  3. For capsicum paste in marinades: Use piquillo pepper paste for mild spiciness
  4. For capsicum paste in soups: Use tomato paste with bell pepper for acidity
  5. For capsicum paste in casseroles: Use sun-dried tomato paste for intensity

Questions

5 questions

What's the best substitute for capsicum paste?

Bell pepper paste is the best substitute for capsicum paste. Use equal amounts by volume. Bell pepper paste has similar sweetness and texture to capsicum paste.

Can I use roasted red pepper paste instead of capsicum paste?

Yes, roasted red pepper paste works well as a capsicum paste substitute. Use equal amounts by volume. Roasted red pepper paste has a slightly different flavor but similar sweetness.

What can I use instead of capsicum paste in cooking?

For cooking, use bell pepper paste for similar results, roasted red pepper paste for added depth, or piquillo pepper paste for mild spiciness.

How do I substitute capsicum paste in recipes?

For recipes, use bell pepper paste for the most similar results, roasted red pepper paste for complexity, or piquillo pepper paste for mild heat.

Can I use tomato paste instead of capsicum paste?

Yes, tomato paste with bell pepper works as a capsicum paste substitute. Use equal amounts by volume. Tomato paste has a different flavor but similar texture.

All 3 capsicum substitutes All ingredients