Skip to content

Out of Chili pepper, one case

Chili pepper substitute

10 options, ranked, with the exact amount

Use thisBest of 10 options

Use Fresh red bell pepper + cayenne

Same amount as the chili pepper

Plus ¼ tsp cayenne per pepper

The best chili pepper substitutes depend on the form needed: for fresh peppers use bell peppers or jalapeños, for dried use red pepper flakes or cayenne powder, and for ground use paprika with cayenne or specific chili powders like ancho or chipotle.

Verdict —
Tweak it
What changes —
different taste, similar texture
Best for —
fresh pepper texture

One casethe full ancho chili paste card

Every option, one card

Ranked
Chili pepper substitutes compared
SubstituteInstead of chili pepper
Fresh red bell pepper + cayennefresh pepper textureSame amountPlus ¼ tsp cayenne per pepperTweak it
Jalapeño peppersfresh peppersSame amountTweak it
Red pepper flakesdried peppersSame amountTweak it
Cayenne pepper powderground peppersSame amountWorks
Paprika + cayennecolor and heat2 parts paprika to 1 part cayenneWorks
Ancho chili powderMexican cuisineSame amountTweak it
Chipotle chili powdersmoky dishesSame amountTweak it
Korean chili powder (gochugaru)Korean cookingSame amountYou'll taste it
Thai chili powderThai cuisineSame amountTweak it
Hot sauceliquid formSame amountTweak it
What changes10 options

Fresh red bell pepper + cayenne

different taste, similar texture

Mild bell pepper provides the bulk and texture of fresh chili peppers, while cayenne adds the heat. Good for when you want fresh pepper texture without overwhelming spice.

Best for
fresh pepper texture, mild heat preference, stir-fries, salsas, when you want bulk

Use red bell pepper for sweetness and color, then add cayenne powder to taste. This works well when the recipe calls for fresh chili peppers but you want less heat.

Jalapeño peppers

different taste, similar texture

Fresh jalapeños provide similar heat level to many chili peppers with a distinct flavor. Good substitute for medium-heat fresh chili peppers.

Best for
fresh peppers, medium heat, Mexican cuisine, salsas, when you want fresh heat

Jalapeños are milder than many chili peppers but provide good fresh heat. Remove seeds and membranes for less heat, keep them for more spice.

Red pepper flakes

similar taste, different texture

Dried and crushed red peppers that provide heat and flavor. Good substitute for dried chili peppers or when you need heat without fresh pepper texture.

Best for
dried peppers, pizza, pasta, when texture doesn't matter, quick heat addition

Red pepper flakes are coarser than ground chili powder but provide similar heat. They work well in most cooked applications.

Cayenne pepper powder

similar taste and texture

Ground cayenne peppers with consistent heat level. Excellent substitute for ground chili peppers or when you need reliable, predictable heat.

Best for
ground peppers, consistent heat, spice blends, when you need powder form, baking

Cayenne powder is hotter than most chili powders but provides consistent, reliable heat. Start with less and adjust to taste.

Paprika + cayenne

similar taste and texture

Mild paprika provides color and base flavor while cayenne adds heat. Great for replicating the flavor profile of many chili peppers.

Best for
color and heat, mild to medium heat, Hungarian cuisine, when you want complexity, spice blends

Adjust the ratio based on desired heat level. Use sweet paprika for mild heat, hot paprika for more spice.

Ancho chili powder

different taste, similar texture

Ground ancho chilies with rich, smoky flavor and mild to medium heat. Good for Mexican and Southwestern dishes that call for chili peppers.

Best for
Mexican cuisine, smoky flavor, mole sauces, when you want depth, mild heat preference

Ancho powder has a distinctive smoky, slightly sweet flavor. It's less hot than cayenne but adds excellent complexity to dishes.

Chipotle chili powder

different taste, similar texture

Ground smoked jalapeños with distinctive smoky flavor and medium heat. Excellent for adding smokiness along with heat.

Best for
smoky dishes, BBQ recipes, Southwestern cuisine, when you want smokiness, medium heat

Chipotle powder has a unique smoky flavor from the smoking process. It's good when you want to add both heat and smokiness.

Korean chili powder (gochugaru)

different taste and texture

Korean red pepper powder with mild to medium heat and slightly sweet, fruity flavor. Essential for Korean cuisine and kimchi making.

Best for
Korean cooking, kimchi, Korean BBQ, Asian dishes, when you want mild heat

Gochugaru has a unique flavor profile that's slightly sweet and fruity. It's coarser than regular chili powder and essential for authentic Korean dishes.

Thai chili powder

different taste, similar texture

Ground Thai chilies with high heat and distinctive flavor. Good for Thai cuisine and when you need authentic Thai heat level.

Best for
Thai cuisine, high heat, curries, when you want authentic Thai flavor, spicy dishes

Thai chili powder is typically much hotter than regular chili powder. Use sparingly and adjust to your heat tolerance.

Hot sauce

similar taste, different texture

Liquid form of hot peppers that provides heat and flavor. Good substitute when you need liquid form or want to add heat to liquids.

Best for
liquid form, marinades, sauces, beverages, when you need liquid heat

Hot sauce contains additional ingredients like vinegar and salt. Adjust other seasonings accordingly and choose a sauce that matches your desired heat level.

How it behaves in this recipe

In this recipeChili pepper

Chili peppers come in many forms (fresh, dried, ground) and heat levels, making substitution complex. The best substitute depends on the specific type of chili pepper, the form needed (fresh vs. dried vs. ground), the heat level required, and the cuisine you're cooking.

Tips for substituting chili pepper

10 tips
  1. When substituting fresh peppers, consider both heat level and flavor profile of the original
  2. For dried peppers, you can often substitute ground versions at a 1:1 ratio
  3. Start with less heat and add more gradually - you can always add more spice but can't remove it
  4. Different chili peppers work better in different cuisines - choose based on your recipe's origin
  5. Fresh peppers can be roasted or charred to add smoky flavor similar to chipotle
  6. When using ground substitutes for fresh peppers, add them later in cooking to preserve flavor
  7. Store dried chili peppers and powders in airtight containers away from light and heat
  8. Test your substitute in a small batch before using in the full recipe
  9. Consider the Scoville heat units when substituting - not all peppers have the same heat level
  10. For authentic flavors, use region-specific chili peppers (ancho for Mexican, gochugaru for Korean, etc.)

Notes on chili pepper

Also on file7 notes
  1. Use fresh peppers and roast them for smoky flavor similar to chipotle
  2. Create custom blends by mixing different types of ground peppers
  3. Use chili paste or hot sauce as liquid alternatives in some recipes
  4. Experiment with smoked salts and spices to add complexity without heat
  5. Try different regional chili peppers for authentic cuisine-specific flavors
  6. Use bell peppers for bulk and add heat with other spices
  7. Make your own chili powder by grinding dried chilies with spices

Questions

10 questions

Can I substitute cayenne pepper for chili powder?

Yes, but cayenne is typically hotter than chili powder. Use about ¾ the amount of cayenne for the same heat level, or mix it with paprika for a more balanced flavor.

What's the best substitute for fresh red chili peppers?

For fresh red chili peppers, use red bell peppers with cayenne powder, jalapeños, or serrano peppers depending on your desired heat level. Red bell peppers provide bulk without heat, while jalapeños offer moderate heat.

Can I use red pepper flakes instead of chili powder?

Yes, red pepper flakes can substitute for chili powder, but they have a coarser texture. Use the same amount, but consider grinding them finer if texture matters in your dish.

What's the best substitute for Thai chili peppers?

For Thai chili peppers, use serrano peppers, jalapeños, or cayenne powder. Thai chilies are very hot, so start with less of your substitute and adjust to taste.

Can I substitute bell peppers for chili peppers?

Yes, but bell peppers have no heat. Use them for bulk and texture, then add cayenne powder, red pepper flakes, or hot sauce to provide the missing heat.

What's the difference between chili powder and cayenne pepper?

Chili powder is a blend of ground chilies and spices (usually cumin, garlic, oregano), while cayenne is just ground cayenne peppers. Chili powder has more complex flavor and is typically less hot than pure cayenne.

Can I use paprika instead of chili powder?

Paprika alone won't provide enough heat. Mix it with cayenne pepper (2:1 ratio) to create a chili powder substitute with similar heat and color.

What's the best substitute for ancho chili peppers?

For ancho chili peppers, use regular chili powder, chipotle powder, or a mix of paprika and cayenne. Ancho has a smoky, slightly sweet flavor, so choose based on whether you want the smokiness.

Can I substitute dried chili peppers for fresh ones?

Yes, but you'll need to rehydrate dried peppers first. Soak them in warm water for 20-30 minutes, then use them like fresh peppers. The flavor will be more concentrated.

What's the best substitute for Korean chili peppers (gochugaru)?

For gochugaru, use regular chili powder mixed with a pinch of sugar, or use mild chili powder. Gochugaru has a unique sweet, fruity flavor that's hard to replicate exactly.

All 3 ancho chili paste substitutes All ingredients