Torch Ginger substitute
Frozen or Dried Sliced Bunga Kantan
Use the same amount by volume for frozen; about 1 tbsp dried per fresh bud, soaked 10 minutes as the torch ginger you are replacing
The real thing, preserved, which most Asian groceries stock even when the fresh buds are out of season.
Other torch ginger substitutes
Ranked, with the exact amount to use
Substitutes for Torch Ginger with ratios
2Lemongrass + Lime Juice
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- assam laksa, fish head curry, soups, sambal
Lemongrass covers the fragrant floral-citrus direction and the lime covers the tartness, and together they read as plausible Southeast Asian perfume. What is missing is the specific soapy-rose smell of the bud, which nothing else in a normal kitchen has, so the broth smells brighter and grassier and less heady. Slice the lemongrass across the grain as thin as you can and add the lime off the heat, since boiling flattens it.
3Lemongrass + Ginger + Lime Zest
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- curries, long-simmered broths, sambal, grilled fish marinades
The ginger supplies a rhizome warmth that hints at the fact that torch ginger is in the ginger family, and the zest supplies the high floral note that lemongrass lacks. The trade-off is a peppery bite that the bud does not have, so keep the ginger small and use young ginger if you can find it. This is the best blend for a dish that simmers, because all three ingredients survive heat better than the bud does.
4Kaffir Lime Leaf + Lemongrass
Taste and texture differWhat changes
- Best for
- coconut curries, rendang, steamed fish, laksa lemak
Lime leaf is the most powerfully floral thing most kitchens can get and it fills the aromatic hole convincingly, but it is unmistakably lime leaf, so the dish smells more Thai and less Malay. Use it where the broth is rich and coconutty rather than in a sharp assam broth, and if the recipe already calls for lime leaves, add these on top of them rather than counting them twice.
5Thinly Sliced Rhubarb
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- assam laksa, sour fish soups, when you want the texture as well as the sourness
Raw torch ginger has a crisp, juicy, mouth-puckering bite, and thin rhubarb is the closest common vegetable to that. It supplies acidity and crunch and no floral aroma whatsoever, so pair it with a bruised lime leaf. Add it late, because rhubarb collapses into strings in about eight minutes, and skip the sugar you would use in a dessert.
6Leave It Out and Add Acid at the Table
Different tasteWhat changes
- Best for
- sambal, spice pastes with many aromatics, weeknight cooking
In a sambal kecombrang the bud is the dish, so this is not the route. But in a laksa or a fish curry with lemongrass, galangal, lime leaf and tamarind already in the pot, dropping the torch ginger costs you one layer of perfume rather than the whole flavour. Nudge the tamarind up by a teaspoon and put lime wedges on the table, and it will taste like a good curry that is missing something rather than a broken one.
What is Torch Ginger?
Torch Ginger is Torch ginger is the tight, unopened pink flower bud of Etlingera elatior, sold as bunga kantan in Malaysia and as kecombrang or honje in Indonesia, and sliced paper thin for its sour, floral, faintly rhubarb-like perfume.
Cooking tips
- Slice the bud crosswise as thin as you possibly can, then add it in the last three to five minutes of cooking. Long boiling turns torch ginger soapy and slightly bitter, which is the single most common way people ruin it, and it also destroys the fragrance you paid for.
- The bud is layered like a tight artichoke. The pale inner core is tender enough to eat raw in a kerabu or nasi ulam, while the tougher outer bracts are better dropped into a simmering broth and pulled out at the end. Splitting one bud between both jobs is normal.
- Freeze whole buds in a sealed bag and they hold their aroma for about three months, far longer than the four or five days they last fresh in the fridge. Slice them straight from frozen, because a thawed bud goes limp and watery and shreds under the knife.
- It is not spicy. Despite the name and the family, torch ginger has no pungent heat at all, so do not adjust the chilli in a recipe on its account, and do not treat it as a swap for ginger root or galangal in the spice paste.
- If a recipe asks for it raw in a salad, dress it right before serving. Cut surfaces go brown and the perfume fades within about twenty minutes, so slice last, not first.
Frequently asked questions
Can I just leave torch ginger out of assam laksa?
Is torch ginger the same as ginger root?
What is bunga kantan and is it different from kecombrang?
Can I use ginger flower powder or a bottled paste?
Where do I buy torch ginger?
Related substitutes
More spices & herbs substitutes