Cream of Tartar substitutes
Cream of Tartar is potassium bitartrate, a dry white acid powder left behind in wine barrels during fermentation, used to fire baking soda, to hold an egg-white foam together, and to stop sugar syrups turning grainy.
Lemon Juice
Use ½ tsp for every ⅛ tsp
It depends which of its three jobs you need. Stabilizing egg whites for meringue: use 1/2 tsp lemon juice or white vinegar per 1/8 tsp cream of tartar, which is per egg white. Leavening, as in snickerdoodles or homemade baking powder: use 1 tsp baking powder in place of 1/4 tsp baking soda plus 1/2 tsp cream of tartar, and remove the soda. Stopping candy from going grainy: use 1 tbsp light corn syrup per cup of sugar.
At a glance
| # | Substitute | Instead of cream of tartar, use | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lemon Juice | ½ tsp per ⅛ tsp | Needs a tweak |
| 2 | White Vinegar | ½ tsp per ⅛ tsp | Needs a tweak |
| 3 | Tartaric Acid | ½ as much | Needs a tweak |
| 4 | Citric Acid | ⅓ as much | Needs a tweak |
| 5 | Baking Powder | 1 tsp for soda + tartar | You'll taste it |
| 6 | Corn Syrup | 1 tbsp per cup sugar | You'll taste it |
| 7 | Leave It Out | nothing added | You'll taste it |
Every cream of tartar substitute
Substitutes for Cream of Tartar with ratios
1. Lemon Juice
Needs a tweakUse ½ tsp for every ⅛ tsp
A liquid acid at roughly 5 to 6% citric acid, strong enough to do the pH work that stabilizes an egg-white foam.
What changes
Likely in your cupboardvegangluten-freedairy-free- Covers
- Acid
- Sweetness
- Aeration
2. White Vinegar
Needs a tweakUse ½ tsp for every ⅛ tsp
Distilled vinegar at about 5% acetic acid, colourless and with no fruit sugars in it.
What changes
Likely in your cupboardvegangluten-freedairy-free- Covers
- Acid
- Aeration
3. Tartaric Acid
Needs a tweak½ as much
The free acid that cream of tartar is the half-neutralized potassium salt of, sold to winemakers and bakers as a fine dry powder.
What changes
Special tripvegangluten-freedairy-free- Covers
- Acid
- Sweetness
- Leavening
- Aeration
4. Citric Acid
Needs a tweak⅓ as much
The dry sour powder sold as sour salt or for home preserving, with three acid groups per molecule.
What changes
Special tripvegangluten-freedairy-free- Covers
- Acid
- Sweetness
- Aeration
5. Baking Powder
You'll taste it1 tsp for soda + tartar
Baking soda already blended with a powdered acid, which is to say cream of tartar's leavening job sold ready-paired.
What changes
Likely in your cupboardvegangluten-freedairy-free- Covers
- Leavening
- Misses
- Acid — not covered
- Sweetness — not covered
- Aeration — not covered
6. Corn Syrup
You'll taste itUse 1 tbsp for every cup sugar
A glucose syrup that is already the kind of sugar cream of tartar creates in the pan, so it blocks crystals from the moment it goes in.
What changes
Likely in your cupboardvegangluten-freedairy-free- Covers
- Sweetness
- Misses
- Acid — not covered
- Leavening — not covered
- Aeration — not covered
7. Leave It Out
You'll taste itnothing added
A real option in one narrow case: a well-sugared egg-white foam made in a scrupulously clean, dry, grease-free bowl.
What changes
Likely in your cupboardvegangluten-freedairy-free- Misses
- Acid — not covered
- Sweetness — not covered
- Leavening — not covered
- Aeration — not covered
Which one for your recipe?
You are whipping egg whites: meringue, pavlova, macarons, angel food cake, royal icing, a meringue topping for pie.
You need acidity and nothing else, so a liquid acid works fine. Use 1/2 tsp lemon juice or white vinegar per 1/8 tsp of cream of tartar, which is the usual dose per egg white, and add it once the whites are foamy rather than at the very start.
The recipe pairs cream of tartar with baking soda — snickerdoodles, some scones and biscuits, homemade baking powder.
Here it is the leavening acid, so replace the pair rather than just the tartar: take out both the cream of tartar and the baking soda, and put in 1 tsp of baking powder for every 1/2 tsp cream of tartar plus 1/4 tsp soda. You will get the rise. What you will not get is the tang, which in a snickerdoodle is half the point.
You are boiling sugar — candy, caramel, boiled or seven-minute frosting, fondant, marshmallow, lemon curd syrup.
The job is stopping crystals forming, and the strongest household answer is not another acid but an invert sugar. Use 1 tbsp light corn syrup per cup of sugar. Lemon juice also works at 1/4 tsp per cup but adds water you then have to boil off.
The recipe lists a small pinch of cream of tartar and nothing else depends on it.
In a plain meringue made in a spotlessly clean dry bowl with a full weight of sugar, you can leave it out and still get stiff peaks. Read the Leave It Out row for exactly when that holds and when it does not.
Do not pick by which powder looks most like cream of tartar. Pick by which of its three jobs your recipe needs. Whipping egg whites? Any liquid acid does it: 1/2 tsp lemon juice or white vinegar per white. Paired with baking soda in a dough? That is leavening — pull out both and put in 1 tsp baking powder per 1/2 tsp tartar plus 1/4 tsp soda, and accept that the tang goes with it. Boiling a sugar syrup? The job is blocking crystals, and 1 tbsp corn syrup per cup of sugar does it better than any acid.
Don’t substitute cream of tartar here
A recipe that pairs cream of tartar with baking soda, and you plan to remove only the cream of tartar.
The cream of tartar is the acid that makes that soda work. Take it out and leave the soda in, and there is nothing for the soda to react with: no rise, and the flat soapy taste of leftover alkali.
Using baking powder to stabilize meringue, pavlova or royal icing.
Baking powder's acid is already paired with its own baking soda and is spent on making gas. It does not lower the pH of the egg white, and the gas it releases puts coarse bubbles through a foam you spent ten minutes making fine.
Boiling vinegar into a candy or caramel syrup in place of cream of tartar.
As the water boils away, the acetic acid concentrates and the smell becomes overwhelming in a way it never does in a meringue.
Home canning, pickling, fermenting or curing — using cream of tartar, or swapping between citric acid, lemon juice and vinegar in a tested recipe.
Acidity is the safety control in preserved food, and these acids are not interchangeable by volume. Reducing the acidity of a canned food creates conditions in which Clostridium botulinum can grow, and the result can be fatal.
Royal icing or a cocktail sour made with raw, unpasteurized egg white.
Cream of tartar and its substitutes lower the pH a little, but not nearly enough to make raw egg white safe. Raw shell eggs can carry Salmonella.
What cream of tartar does in a recipe
Cream of tartar is an acid that happens to be dry. That is how it can fire baking soda from inside the flour, hold an egg-white foam together, and stop a boiling sugar syrup turning grainy.
Tips for substituting cream of tartar
- Cream of tartar is doing one of three completely different jobs in any given recipe: firing baking soda, stabilizing an egg-white foam, or stopping sugar crystallizing. Work out which one before you substitute anything.
- The usual dose in a meringue is 1/8 tsp per egg white, and 1/2 tsp of lemon juice or white vinegar takes its place exactly.
- Add any acid to egg whites once they have gone foamy and opaque, not into the clear raw whites. Acid added too early slows the foam down noticeably.
- For a white meringue or white royal icing, choose distilled white vinegar over lemon juice: no fruit sugar means no tint and no browning.
- If a recipe lists cream of tartar and baking soda together, they are a pair. Removing one and not the other is the single commonest way this substitution goes wrong.
- In candy and boiled frosting, an invert sugar beats an acid. A tablespoon of light corn syrup per cup of sugar blocks crystals from the start, where cream of tartar has to invert some of your sucrose in the pan first.
- Once a hot sugar syrup is clear, stop stirring and stop scraping the sides. Agitation is what starts crystals growing, no matter what you have added to prevent it.
- Snickerdoodles are the one cookie where cream of tartar is a flavour ingredient. Swap it for baking powder and you get the rise but not the tang, and the result tastes like a cinnamon sugar cookie.
- A hard clump in an old tub is not spoilage — crush it and use it. What ruins cream of tartar is damp, not age.