Skip to content

Chocolate Cookie Crumbs substitute

Best substitute

Graham cracker crumbs plus cocoa

Use the same amount by weight, plus 3 tbsp Dutch-process cocoa and 1 tbsp sugar per 1 ½ cups of crumbs, with the full 5 to 6 tbsp melted butter as the chocolate cookie crumbs you are replacing

Best for cheesecake bases

Different taste

The standard American crumb crust base, darkened and deepened with cocoa powder.

Other chocolate cookie crumbs substitutes

Ranked, with the exact amount to use

Substitutes for Chocolate Cookie Crumbs with ratios

  1. 2Chocolate graham crackers or chocolate animal crackers

    Close match

    Use the same amount by weight, with the full 5 to 6 tbsp butter per 1 ½ cups

    Chocolate versions of the crackers already sold for crumb crusts, and the easiest genuine match.

    What changes
    Best for
    cheesecake bases, pie crusts, no-bake desserts, crumb toppings, parfait layers

    The closest low-effort swap and often cheaper than sandwich cookies. Because there is no creme filling, the fat content matches plain graham crumbs, so use the standard butter quantity with no adjustment. The flavour is a shade sweeter, milder and more milk-chocolate-ish than the bittersweet crust you get from real chocolate wafers, and the crumb is slightly softer, giving a marginally more tender base rather than a crisp snap. Chocolate teddy-shaped grahams and chocolate animal crackers behave identically and are often in the house already.

  2. 3Chocolate wafer cookies or thin chocolate biscuits

    Close match

    Use the same amount by weight, with 5 tbsp butter per 1 ½ cups

    Thin, crisp, barely sweet dark chocolate cookies, which are what most older recipes actually meant.

    What changes
    Best for
    cheesecake bases, icebox cakes, pie crusts, crumb toppings, truffle coatings

    Arguably the original rather than the substitute, and the best-tasting option on this list. Thin chocolate wafers are very dry and low in both fat and sugar, so the crust comes out crisper, darker and considerably less sweet, which is a real advantage under a very sweet filling like a caramel or a milk-chocolate mousse. Because there is no filling fat, they need the full butter, unlike sandwich cookie crumbs. The classic American thin chocolate wafer has been discontinued, so look for imported chocolate thins, chocolate snaps or chocolate shortbread thins instead.

  3. 4Chocolate shortbread, chocolate biscotti or brownie brittle, crushed

    Different texture

    Use the same amount by weight, but cut the butter to 3 to 4 tbsp per 1 ½ cups

    Richer chocolate biscuits crushed for a crust, which already carry a lot of their own fat.

    What changes
    Best for
    cheesecake bases, tart shells, no-bake bars, crumb toppings

    All three make an excellent crust with one important adjustment: they are considerably fattier than graham crackers, so the standard butter quantity turns the base oily and it will slump rather than set. Cut to three or four tablespoons and use the squeeze test, where a handful should hold together like damp sand rather than feel slick. Chocolate shortbread gives the most buttery, tender crust, biscotti the crunchiest and most rustic, and brownie brittle the most intensely fudgy and the sweetest. Pre-bake any of them for ten minutes at 350F to set the base properly.

  4. 5Vanilla wafer or digestive biscuit crumbs plus cocoa

    Different taste

    Use the same amount by weight, plus 3 tbsp cocoa and 1 tbsp sugar per 1 ½ cups, with 4 to 5 tbsp butter

    Plain sweet biscuits taken chocolate with cocoa powder.

    What changes
    Best for
    cheesecake bases, pie crusts, no-bake tarts, icebox desserts

    Both work and both taste noticeably different from a chocolate cookie crust. Vanilla wafers are sweeter and softer and already contain a fair amount of fat, so drop the butter by a tablespoon and expect a sandy, tender, distinctly vanilla-scented base with the cocoa sitting on top of it rather than blended in. Digestives are drier, wheatier and less sweet, which makes a sturdier crust with a nutty, slightly oaty background that suits a rich chocolate filling well. Neither will pass for a chocolate sandwich cookie crust, but both give a perfectly good pie.

  5. 6Gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies

    Different texture

    Use the same amount by weight, with 2 to 3 tbsp butter per 1 ½ cups, and pre-bake the crust

    Gluten-free versions of the same product, now widely stocked.

    What changes
    Best for
    gluten-free cheesecake bases, gluten-free pies, no-bake bars, crumb toppings

    Substitute straight across, filling included, and keep the butter low as you would with any filled cookie. The difference is fragility: gluten-free cookies are made with rice and starch blends that absorb butter differently and produce a crumb that is more powdery and less inclined to hold together, so press the base very firmly with the flat bottom of a glass and always pre-bake for ten minutes at 350F even if the filling is no-bake. The flavour is close, usually a touch sweeter and slightly less cocoa-forward.

  6. 7Crushed chocolate cereal

    Taste and texture differ

    1 ½ cups crushed cereal to 4 tbsp melted butter plus 1 tbsp corn syrup or honey

    Chocolate rice or corn cereal crushed fine, for a no-bake base when there are no cookies in the house.

    What changes
    Best for
    no-bake bars, freezer desserts, ice cream pie crusts, toppings

    The honest last resort, and it does hold together thanks to the corn syrup, which acts as glue where a cereal's low fat and low sugar would otherwise leave the base loose. Expect a brittle, slightly airy crust with visible texture rather than the dense sandy shell a cookie crust gives, and a much milder, milkier chocolate flavour. It works best in the freezer, where the butter stays firm, so it is a reasonable base for an ice cream pie and a poor one for a baked cheesecake.

What is Chocolate Cookie Crumbs?

Chocolate Cookie Crumbs is the name for crushed chocolate cookies, usually chocolate sandwich cookies or thin chocolate wafers, bound with melted butter to press a dark crumb crust or scattered to layer and top desserts.

Cooking tips

  • Do not scrape the filling out of sandwich cookies for a crust. The creme is sugar and fat, both of which the crust wants, and leaving it in means you need far less butter. Blitz the cookies whole, filling and all, then add butter 1 tablespoon at a time until a squeezed handful holds its shape, usually only 2 to 4 tablespoons per 1 1/2 cups against 5 to 6 for plain graham crumbs.
  • Weigh the cookies rather than counting them. A 9-inch crumb crust wants roughly 6 to 7 ounces, or 170 to 200 g, of cookies, which is somewhere around 15 to 18 standard chocolate sandwich cookies including their filling. Brands and sizes vary enormously, so weighing is the only way to get the same crust twice, and crush a couple extra for patching the sides.
  • Pre-bake the crust for 10 minutes at 350F even for a no-bake filling. That short bake sets the butter and sugar into a solid shell that resists a wet filling and slices cleanly instead of crumbling. Skipping it is the reason so many no-bake pies have a base that stays sandy at the bottom of the tin.
  • Chocolate cookie crumbs are doing more than flavour: they are a dry starch scaffold, they are the sweetness at the bottom of the dessert and they are the bitter contrast that stops a rich cheesecake tasting flat. That last part is why a plain graham crust under a chocolate filling can taste cloying, and why adding cocoa to graham crumbs genuinely improves the finished pie rather than just changing its colour.
  • A food processor gives a fine uniform powder, which is what you want for a crust that holds a clean edge. For a topping or a layered dessert, a zip-top bag and a rolling pin leave some bigger pieces, which look and eat much better. Choose the tool for the job rather than defaulting to the machine.
  • Cool the crust completely before filling. Warm butter is liquid, so a still-warm crust will absorb a wet filling and go soggy, and a warm base under a cheesecake batter can begin to melt into it. Fifteen minutes in the fridge after the pre-bake is enough.

Frequently asked questions

Should I scrape the creme filling out of the cookies?

No. The filling is sugar and fat, both of which the crust needs, and leaving it in means using much less butter. Blitz the cookies whole and add butter a tablespoon at a time, stopping at 2 to 4 tablespoons per 1 1/2 cups of crumbs. If you do scrape the filling out, treat the crumbs like plain graham crumbs and use the full 5 to 6 tablespoons instead.

Can I use graham cracker crumbs instead of chocolate cookie crumbs?

Yes, 1:1 by weight, and the crust will behave identically. To close the flavour gap, whisk 3 tablespoons of Dutch-process cocoa and 1 tablespoon of sugar into each 1 1/2 cups of crumbs and add a pinch of salt, keeping the full butter since graham crumbs are lean and cocoa is drying. The crust will still be lighter in colour and sweeter than one made from chocolate cookies.

How many cookies do I need for a 9-inch crust?

About 6 to 7 ounces, or 170 to 200 g, of cookies, which works out to roughly 15 to 18 standard chocolate sandwich cookies with the filling left in, or a similar weight of chocolate wafers or grahams. Weigh rather than count, since cookie sizes differ wildly between brands, and crush a small handful extra so you have enough to build the sides.

Can I make the dessert without a crumb crust at all?

Yes, for most fillings. Line a springform tin with parchment and bake or chill a crustless cheesecake, which sets perfectly well and slices cleanly if you run a hot knife round the edge first. For pudding and mousse pies, spoon the filling into glasses or ramekins instead. What you lose is the textural contrast and the bittersweet note, so consider scattering crushed cookies or cocoa nibs over the top instead.

Why is my chocolate crumb crust greasy or falling apart?

Greasy almost always means too much butter, and with filled sandwich cookies that happens easily because the creme already supplies fat. Cut back to 2 or 3 tablespoons per 1 1/2 cups and use the squeeze test. Falling apart usually means the opposite, too little butter, or that the base was not pressed firmly enough and never pre-baked. Press hard with the flat bottom of a glass and bake it for 10 minutes at 350F before filling.

Related substitutes

More baking substitutes

Need a different ingredient?

Browse the full index, or the rest of this category.

Browse all substitutesMore baking